Like do people just type anything these days
Like I understand having subjective opinions about art and music but out right making up lies is indeed funny.
where is the lie? Or tell me what kind of impact they brought to the industry? I said they helped to expand kpop into global sphere and there pretty much their impact ends…
I find it funny when u said all that to justify placing BP lower BUT instead putting Twice at #2. Cause Twice doesnt have those you said too except for richer discography. Each member of twice is not iconic, or not even close to being well known except 1-2. Their concept was mainly inherited from SNSD (JYP himself said) so there is nothing innovative
snsd and twice don’t have the same sound
2ne1 and bp do
Also twice’s discography >>>> bp’s discography
Also twice as performers >>>> bp and none of these groups have icons but twice members are closer to become like that!
Both groups are pretty average when it comes to singing
Bp tt’s since 4D are basically the same
Groups discographies and their impact to the industry has heavy weight in my ranking
Then comes talents and charts
That’s why bp is at 6th place
Btw I don’t Stan a single gg from my top 10 list
Submit your application to the Girl Group Council run by yours truly
Wow. And people used to think I was the de facto BP anti around here. Another bold take.
The latter.
I’m not a bp anti😅
I just don’t find anything iconic in BP
But my bias is LISA and so far I liked her every single solo release this year(she is my 3rd most streamed kpop artist this year on yt music) 
As YHS said himself BP is a replacement of 2NE1 so I can’t just place them that high, if not for their chart achievements I wouldn’t include them to the list! Cuz 1st they have very short discography, 2nd they didn’t have any impact to the industry music wise or concept wise, also individual members of bp aren’t iconic idols themselves! So I placed them at 6 for helping to expand kpop and for their chart achievements
No I only know several 1st gen boy groups and only 1 gg which is S.E.S., but 1st gen ggs have no significant impact except S.E.S. compared to boygroups of 1st gen! I guess BoA took all the impact for female counterparts
Yeah in order
And I edited and added honorable mentions list
1. SNSD
2. Twice
5. f(x)
6. Blackpink
7. S.E.S.
8. Wonder Girls
9. Sistar
10. Davichi
Honourable mentions: Mamamoo, Kara, T-Ara, APINK and MissA
No 4th gen gg is qualified yet to be in this list
I included impact to the industry music wise and concept wise(hence bp is at 6th place), discography, charts to some extent and of course some kind of subjective feeling or opinion!
Old sweaters
Positive opinions
Cute songs and concepts suit every single member of the group, I don’t understand why people keep pushing that girl crush narrative!
They are pretty good dancers
Negative opinions:
No stage presence, no star quality or aura, below average vocals, short TikTok songs like newjeans, either too much autotune in their songs or cursive singing! Also I genuinely thought that they were njs when magnetic came out!
They should’ve debuted at least a year later after serious training with their vocals and stage presence
Why is this a must?
To showcase that their vocals improved of course! As I said earlier every regular person without vocal training or talents can sound the same in the studio if they learn this song! There is nothing hard to sing in this song at least for tenors and females!
Also their extremely underdeveloped vocals shows even in studio versions of their songs especially in most of their tts except perfect night and fearless!
Anyways lsfm needs extremely serious vocal training cuz they will start touring at some point and then you can just wait for hate tsunami to come after them! Or if they will lipsing then people will be turned off and again hate will come after them!
Positive things
They are best dance oriented 4th gen gg
They are good performers
They have strong identity
Brave girls for standing up against a conglomerate
Negative opinions
Most of their discography consist of snooze fest songs! Also I don’t like how they incorporate ads excessively into their mvs, which takes away from the artistry! Their songs are exactly what TikTok songs look like, also they are extremely short! Their singing is really average! Many of their songs sound the same hence you get bored really quickly! Also I still can’t differentiate the girls except Hanni and Danielle because of mhj’s “natural” looks with same hairstyle and colour! That’s why they will be strong as a group but not as an individual artist!
Poll
No bc megathread has so much useless information insults and other random things that regular person gets tired filtering and reading all that! It is good that we have separate thread for this cuz more people will see the actual news
Karina is even outpacing the IT boy of Korea Cha Eun Woo🔥
She is Number 1 most searched idol overall
External Content
x.com
Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
I don’t if mys have heard it but I will tag them
MyTaglist
This is my fav Aespa ost😅
I voted for the first time after being a kpop Stan for 5 years😅
