Posts by ill-pray-4-u
-
-
Internationally they already passed SNSD had quite a while ago, by miles.
Domestically is arguable. BP has surpassed many of SNSD's "strong points" or records, but there are still many areas where they are behind. -
-
Probably after he chooses the worst possible time.
-
i like the bridge more. are sure that there isnt any live blinkeu
They sing the song almost fully live with a backing track that's not very loud. The "Now wait til I do" part is the only part that has never been sung live (as far as I've found/seen).
I like the bridge of KTL and HYLT more than D4's. Don't kill me lol. -
If they stop declining digitally, there's a small chance.
-
-
It is obviously, but some people will stay delusional.
-
External Content youtu.beContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
she has hit higher notes before though
External Content youtu.beContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
She also dodges the "wait til I do" part in that clip, the highest notes. You can clearly hear the parts that are sang, and when it's only backing track. It's easy to her her start singing again from the "hit you with that dudududu" part.
Seems her highest actual live note is Eb5 (D#5) -
not when a group like bp exists. they have stable vocals lmao
They do have stable vocals compared to most of their peers (excluding vocal-oriented groups like mamamoo).
They also rely less on extremely loud backing tracks compared to many groups. They don't get enough credit for that.
Still, Ice Cream was written by Ariana Grande, which speak to its difficulty in places lol. -
wdym?she has hit it before
External Content youtu.beContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.The E5 is the "wait" note in the "now wait til I do, hit you with that dududududu" line. It's dodged in that live as well, just backing track sadly.
-
-
-
-
Was still 1st month of october and stayed very high until December (1st most the time november). Ithink this could be considered a peak. AIIYL peaked at 3rd on Gaon but did stay way longer, if anything i dismissed a little AIIYL success but TT totally deserve to be here.
You talked about end of the year figures, then changed to talking about peaks within months. Lmao.
TT deserves to be there roughly the same amount that AIIYL does considering TT's underwhelming longevity. Both stayed in the top 10 the same amount of time. AIIYL stayed in the top 100 of those charts for more than 4 months longer. It's also the ONLY girl group song to chart on Gaon's streaming chart for 5 straight years.
Not every hit has a massive peak, massive peaks often result in overall disappointing results (especially in Twice's case). Look at Spring Day, it never had a peak even as close as AIIYL did. -
Display More
I don't think PWF is a national hit, i'd say that it's a massive hit.
AIIYL is on a confusing state. I don't know if it deserved to be listed as national hit. It was released at the same day with Mamamoo 'Yes I Am', MMM's song outcharted AIIYL then fall quickly but AIIYL is still on top. AIIYL's longevity is insane, the song started pretty well but not a front-runner. 64 weeks on Gaon Digital TOP100. Maybe its a national hit
DDDD. No explanation needed. Its Ddu-Du-Ddu-Du, the song that revolutionize Blackpink's career forever. The EP was a banger, B-side of the century 'Forever Young' is on that EP.
HYLT. Perhaps the second-biggest idol group song of 2020. The song started massively, and even got 12PAK eventhough the charts keep reforming for 3 times. Longevity-wise, currently on 24Hits TOP30 #31. Great start and great longevity. Indeed a national hit
Lovesick Girls 🤔. The song that i was underestimated, i didnt expect it to do this well. I dont think its a national hit yet, maybe it will after the song pass 18 weeks on MelOn TOP10 weekly chart. Currently 16 weeks on TOP10 (same like Nobody, D4, and HYLT). As for now it's still doing very well (#7). The MelOn reform is a disaster for some artists but its a blessing for Blackpink's song. I believe the song will surpass Cheer Up and Tell Me
AIIYL had 67 weeks on the Gaon digital 100. The most of any girl group song (Cheer Up had 66 weeks on the regular Gaon 100).
Just correcting you on that. -
Actually i think it should be how it is counted, with an emphasis on peak chart positions, and TT did peak really high so it would make the list. KKB had a very huge peak but died in like 2/3 weeks, hard to know the revelency of the song, but had one of the highest peak of any song in 2017. AIIYL never quite reached that kind of a peak so i don't know how to rank it compared to the other high peak/low longevity songs.
For songs that are released at the very end (Psycho, Hip, Meteor), their performance should be counted mostly in 2020 and should be considered 2020 hits as it is the year they marked the most kpop
TT didn't perform super well on neither the 2016 nor 2017 charts due to the time it was released. You're picking and choosing when and where to apply your flawed system.
-
I think Jennie having to hit those E5s live might play a small role. She never did the same note live for D4, but the E5 note in Ddu Ddu Dddu Du is in a good place to dodge it. You can't really dodge that note where it is in Ice Cream. You can kind of hear her struggling to hit it in the studio recording as it is.
I actually like the song and wish they did it too. That's just my opinion because it's literally the only thing I can think of as to why they didn't do it. -
what did i even say wrong?
anyways cheer up was used by the president himself as his election song i dont need to argue with random users that live everywhere but korea about a song which everyone knows is one of the biggest idol songs of all time.
everybody did shy shy shy but did everybody we are the lovesick girls? think about it
Gimmicks don't make a song bigger lmao.
Stay salty about Twice continuing to decline digitally since after Cheer Up rather than getting bigger and bigger hits like BP. -
Ko Ko Bop did beat Red Flavor multiple weeks which i consider a pretty strong feat and Signal was kinda big hit for most of the year. They did lack longevity yes, but imo if you are talking about specific years, you should only talk about performances during that year and they pretty much performed as good as AIIYL during 2017. AIIYL has a very good longevity.
By that flawed logic, song released in the third quarter, or early 4th, or always gonna be outperformed by medium level hits released in the first quarter, just because of time. By this logic, TT was not a national hit in 2016 since it was released so late and had very little time to perform as well as the other songs released earlier in the year.
