Why is 4th gen boy groups so boring?

    The 4th gen girl group battle is interesting and intense and has everyone hyped up but boy groups are boring and no one cares but why?

    discuss

  • Moderator

    Approved the thread.

    There’s only 3 relevant 4th gen bgs… en, skz, txt


    They have no competition tbh

    Its pretty obvious less bgs are debuting from relevant companies and the their isn't much to debate in terms of who's more popular tho bg stans do try.

    Music is monotonous - skz's title tracks are all starting to sound the same plus there's a lot of mid tier boy groups pushing the same sound so it get's boring.

    TXT and enhypen don't have enough personal charisma regardless of good songs. Enhypen in particular because of their lacking vocal talent - music sounds flat after all the processing.

    Quote from Broasted Confit of Mammoth (285)

    Music is monotonous - skz's title tracks are all starting to sound the same plus there's a lot of mid tier boy groups pushing the same sound so it get's boring.

    TXT and enhypen don't have enough personal charisma regardless of good songs. Enhypen in particular because of their lacking vocal talent - music sounds flat after all the processing.

    "Enhypen in particular". Enhypen is much better at vocals than TXT, shut up if you don't know shit.

    Because unlike ggs, the bgs have set leaders already. Nobody is touching skz, en and txt in terms of success and popularity. While with ggs it's still unknown who is on top so that's why it's more fierce there

    because no 4th gen bg is making any noise

    GGs fights were always more intense, because gg stans aren't only in their groups business, but in others too.


    During 3rd gen, apart for EXO vs BTS for around 3 years, which other BGs fanwars were a stand out?


    It has nothing to do with the groups, they are fine.

    skz are the only interesting ones to me, no offence.

    Quote from Broasted Confit of Mammoth (285)

    Music is monotonous - skz's title tracks are all starting to sound the same plus there's a lot of mid tier boy groups pushing the same sound so it get's boring.

    TXT and enhypen don't have enough personal charisma regardless of good songs. Enhypen in particular because of their lacking vocal talent - music sounds flat after all the processing.

    Agree on this. With those groups it's always the same sound, same concept etc. .


    Back then you had


    - Shinee

    - Bigbang

    - Ikon

    - B2ST

    - BTOB

    - Winner


    Those groups did well on the charts where 4th gen boy groups can't even crack Gaon top 100.

    Quote from Baked Saffron Rabbit (979)

    Because unlike ggs, the bgs have set leaders already. Nobody is touching skz, en and txt in terms of success and popularity. While with ggs it's still unknown who is on top so that's why it's more fierce there

    no its because all the boys are on same level and no one has broken out yet with anything exciting. There are multiple girl groups killing it hence why there's more conversation around them

    Do u even know the meaning of charisma? 😂 It’s compelling attractiveness attractiveness or charm that can inspire devotion in others. Enhypen was able to sell millions of albums. Become a million seller in less than a yr. Amass massive supporters in a yr of their career. Their social media followers are top 3, top 2 even in Twitter despite few yrs younger than TxT & SKZ They have already beaten a lot of their seniors on that. And their social engagements is either top 1 or top 2 . They are still top 1 in having the most monthly listeners (8M plus) despite being inactive for almost two months now. They are on their blank period.


    Most charismatic grps usually have massive supporters & haters. So yeah, keep hating coz it will only make them even more popular.

    Quote from Broasted Confit of Mammoth (285)

    Music is monotonous - skz's title tracks are all starting to sound the same plus there's a lot of mid tier boy groups pushing the same sound so it get's boring.

    TXT and enhypen don't have enough personal charisma regardless of good songs. Enhypen in particular because of their lacking vocal talent - music sounds flat after all the processing.

    Because boy groups are above the girl groups' league so while y'all fight about whicu gg charted better on genie, boy groups are busy making history on billboard

    People are still interested in kpop? Both gg and bgs have become boring to me

    because boy groups don't chart. Duh, there is nothing to talk about and do the comparison on melon. They only have sale which nothing much to talk about.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!

Register Yourself Login