Aespa never sings live and never did.

Did you make an account just to bring back all the tired arguments?

Also for the millionth time, backtracks in encores happened a lot before aespa ever had theirs ESPECIALLY in music core (which is where aespa had their first encore). Having a backtrack never made the encore less impressive because the mics in encore always overpower it unlike the stages with backtracks overpowering the voices.

It's crazy how kpop fans agreed on crediting aespa and SM for "changing the system" and "starting backtracks trend" when in fact you all ignored it before no matter how common it was.

It's not aespa's fault that y'all are jealous of them getting good reception over an encore a hard song like Savage.

apparently, aespa started the trend before they debuted

Even with the backtrack on their encore, they were singing.

But yeah, I want to see more live stages and singing from them. I don't think it's an aespa exclusive issue because a lot of groups lipsync but it would be nice.

Yeah it was the aes who sings apparently

The fact that we even have heated debates about ''is it lipsync,pre-recorded or live'' is kinda sad tbh

this isn't just an aespa thing,it's very much become an industry thing.

they didn't lipsync in encore i would love some live stages this year, not all stages have to be live because i also have worries if it's healthy to do so. Anyway recently all the girls post some snippets of them singing so i hope that's a good sign.

oh my gosh, dont you know I am a cabbage?

I hope one day ningning will drop a cover

what you say reminds me of some content on yt "only Ning wanted to sing live (heard above microphone)" when the other girls were definitely heard in their high notes, esp ningning,winter and karina . it's not like you have to change the key just to scream, especially in rap. karina adlibs - definitely audible. direct your pain to sm, write to them, nobody cares, it's not like you've discovered undiscovered.

just yesterday saying that Step back lyrics reeks internalized misogyny now came out with this bs

not much but doesn't mean that they never singing live

exhibit A

turn the cc

they confirmed in behind the scene that it was live

this doesn't change the fact that they still sing better than your faves, go cry somewhere else

Quote from Elbereth

they didn't lipsync in encore i would love some live stages this year, not all stages have to be live because i also have worries if it's healthy to do so. Anyway recently all the girls post some snippets of them singing so i hope that's a good sign.

Apparently having a backtrack is lip-syncing now lol. The best thing about encores live is the fact the live voice overpowers the backtrack if there's one or not.

It was never about not having a backtrack but about their raw voices heard overpowering it, unlike the other "Live" stages. Suddenly when aespa does what all their seniors did, it's a problem and they're cheating.

I am always vocal about disliking how aespa lip-syncs their stages so I am not defending everything.

However, recent kpop fans coming at aespa's encore for having a backtrack just reeks of jealousy. We know how many of these people were anticipating aespa's encore to be a failure.

Remember the trending hashtags filled with non-fans asking where's aespa's encore because it was less than a day late?

It must have felt so bad when they wanted aespa to have a bad encore controversy so much but instead when their encore happened, they got articles praising them. Imagine the damage.

Quote from Yumeku

Apparently having a backtrack is lip-syncing now lol. The best thing about encores live is the fact the live voice overpowers the backtrack if there's one or not.

It was never about not having a backtrack but about their raw voices heard overpowering it, unlike the other "Live" stages. Suddenly when aespa does what all their seniors did, it's a problem and they're cheating.

I am always vocal about disliking how aespa lip-syncs their stages so I am not defending everything.

However, recent kpop fans coming at aespa's encore for having a backtrack just reeks of jealousy. We know how many of these people were anticipating aespa's encore to be a failure.

Remember the trending hashtags filled with non-fans asking where's aespa's encore because it was less than a day late?

It must have felt so bad when they wanted aespa to have a bad encore controversy so much but instead when their encore happened, they got articles praising them. Imagine the damage.

Display More

Lol aespa's encore is such an event, everyone was waiting for it

Quote from icyruios

I'MA CABBAGE I'M SO TASTY RIGHT NOW OHHHHHH

I'MA CABBAGE GONNA COOK ME RIGHT NOW OHHHHHH

COOK ME COOK ME NOW COOK ME COOK ME NOW ZUZUZUZU

EAT ME EAT ME NOW EAT ME EAT ME NOW ZUZUZUZUZU

Display More

It’s silly to say that only NingNing wanted to sing, because you can hear Winter’s real voice very loudly during both encores. Actually, you can hear Karina and Giselle very clearly too.

Very weird how kpoppies token stan NingNing to put down the other girls.

Anyway Aespa are the best vocal girl group to debut recently, I hope SM lets them sing live more

Quote from SooYoung

Some of you need to stop trying to push this fake narrative when they obviously sing live during their encore stage and there was no loud backtrack

at 1:29 anybody can hear that Ningning can't be heard that's why she's asking the staff to increase the volume of her mic because we don't hear her and you can clearly her the difference between the before and after she asked

at 2:25 you can hear that Winter stop singing for a second , because ningning hit the mic when winter was singing, and directly apologize and you can clearly hear that there's no voice in the backtrack during this break when winter isn't singing

at 3:20 Ningning change the way she sing the "i'm savage " part and you can clearly hear her emphasize the "savage" much more than she usually do

we understood that some of you are obsess with the desire of push this aespa never sing live since debut narrative but this performance obviously prove the contrary

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Display More