Which Girl Group is more popular?

To help aid in your determination, here is a *complete* ranking of all music show wins for Second Generation girl groups:

Girls' Generation – 100 wins

Apink – 51 wins

Wonder Girls – 45 wins

2NE1 – 43 wins

Sistar – 43 wins

f(x) – 33 wins

T-ara – 28 wins

Kara – 26 wins

4Minute – 23 wins

EXID – 22 wins

Davichi – 20 wins

Girls' Generation-TTS – 17 wins

Miss A – 15 wins

Brown Eyed Girls – 12 wins

Girl's Day – 12 wins

Sistar19 – 11 wins

AOA – 10 wins

Brave Girls – 10 wins

SeeYa – 6 wins

Secret – 6 wins

After School – 3 wins

The Grace – 2 wins

Crayon Pop – 1 win

^ bUT F(X) hAd NO hitS

This is what happens when people who weren't even around in second gen base things off how much they like the songs now.

Though it is funny that, even after all this time, these forums are still primarily ranking the top 10-15 of second gen and not third or fourth. I suppose at least time has answered the "was 2NE1 or SNSD #1?" question that used to dominate the conversation. There could have been 20 pages dedicated to just arguing that point.

Quote from centen

Though it is funny that, even after all this time, these forums are still primarily ranking the top 10-15 of second gen and not third or fourth.

Quote from icyruios

It would be good if we even have 10 solid contenders to rank 1-10 but there isnt at most maybe 1-6

Just for fun, here is the entire ranking of music show wins for Third Generation girl groups:

Twice – 117 wins

Red Velvet – 80 wins

GFriend – 71 wins

Blackpink – 43 wins

Mamamoo – 42 wins

Oh My Girl – 19 wins

Momoland – 11 wins

I.O.I – 9 wins

Bolbbalgan4 – 9 wins

Cosmic Girls – 9 wins

Lovelyz – 4 wins

CLC – 2 wins

Hi Suhyun – 1 win

Laboum – 1 win

DIA – 1 win

Irene & Seulgi – 1 win

As we can see, there are both fewer total wins and fewer groups represented compared to the Second Generation.

Quote from Lulu_Key

rppm, hot summer, danger some to name

Lmao all of f(x) title tracks flopped on the charts. The only one that did decent was 4walls.