Karina Cbar is the biggest after BP members + Biggest 4th gen idol Cbar :O

so have the bars found a way around the new laws then?

Quote from redcurtain

so have the bars found a way around the new laws then?

They have always been able to buy albums.. they just can't go overboard in terms of fund raising.

Also I noticed on weibo that NingNing has a bunch of smaller groups outside of the main bar bulk buying albums as well. That might be a result of not making the bars too big or eye catching.

Quote from crimsonice

They have always been able to buy albums.. they just can't go overboard in terms of fund raising.

Also I noticed on weibo that NingNing has a bunch of smaller groups outside of the main bar bulk buying albums as well. That might be a result of not making the bars too big or eye catching.

that's good to hear! It's so ridiculous that people should be blocked from supporting artists they care about.

Quote from redcurtain

that's good to hear! It's so ridiculous that people should be blocked from supporting artists they care about.

For sure.. it would be just horrible to be blocked from enjoying their favs.

new queen of china

I thought Sakura's C-bar bought 100k for one of the albums, maybe that was multiple combined

Look at Winter there too! 4th gen queens

Wait NingNing too Giselle will soon join them

3 aespa members in the top 10 for ALL 4th gen idols. The way they are already dominating china despite being 11-month old rookies!

Quote from crimsonice

They have always been able to buy albums.. they just can't go overboard in terms of fund raising.

Also I noticed on weibo that NingNing has a bunch of smaller groups outside of the main bar bulk buying albums as well. That might be a result of not making the bars too big or eye catching.

Ningning and Winter end up being only a few hundred copies apart, I added them up. Karina the next visual killer haha. Ningning would be #4

I'm guessing the girls sold quite a bit more than those numbers in China. Since the crackdown, a lot of the fans are taking a more cautious approach. I see that Ning cfans have multiple bulk buys in addition the main bar.. smaller numbers.. 500-3K purchases, so it's harder to track. I wouldn't be surprised if the other girls' fans are doing the same. What Kbar is did is kinda risky. If I recall, a bunch of bars got suspended, including some SM girls like Seulgi & Taeyeon.

I think moving forward, we will likely not know exactly how many albums cfans buy, except for the companies/stores themselves. The ones who don't keep a lower profile may get suspended unfortunately.

Is this some kind of achievement to be proud about?

was this some high IQ way to bash aespa

Edit:nvm OP is an actual fan