who is most talented member [ace][all-rounder] of aespa

Winter- isn’t she a lead vocalist and a lead dancer , she also has a good charm on stage , why is she last In peoples ranking.

She’s a better dancer than giselle and Ning Ning, personally the best dancer in Aespa for me. She sings better than the rest except Ning Ning, we haven’t heard her rap but looking at the criteria now , she is definitely an ace alongside Karina

the fact it's kinda hard to choose shows how well rounded they are lol

i think it is giselle

Karina she was introduced as the ace of Aespa by SM. She can rap, dance and sing above average.

Quote from Yumeku

It's really hard because literally all of them compete for the ace position. We need more content imo

I think Ningning is better at English than Karina but could be wrong since there's little content.

Karina seemed better and more confident in their Haper's Bazaar interview.

Probably Karina. She's good at dancing, singing, rapping, has the visuals, and is also really quick at picking up languages. She speaks English really well for a non-native speaker and seems to have a great understanding of Chinese and Japanese as well.

Obviously all of them, but I would have to say Giselle or Karina, with Karina having an advantage on Dance, but Giselle having an edge on Rapping. I would probably say Giselle first

I think it’s between Giselle and Karina

They both know how to sing, rap & dance.

Giselle is better at rapping but Karina is better at dancing. as for vocals it’s hard to tell but i’ll lean towards Giselle more only because it’s said that she’s been in choir 4 for years and cause she can hit high notes. both are amazing and all-rounders!

Quote from GoingtoKwangya

I think it’s between Giselle and Karina

They both know how to sing, rap & dance.

Giselle is better at rapping but Karina is better at dancing. as for vocals it’s hard to tell but i’ll lean towards Giselle more only because it’s said that she’s been in choir 4 for years and cause she can hit high notes. both are amazing and all-rounders!

Karina is vocally superior to Giselle she has support and range slightly weaker than Winter Giselle has little to no support and no range she can hit high notes but that doesn't mean they will be good or supported lol

It would be like saying Yeri is a better singer than Joy since she hit Wendy's bad boy notes but they weren't supported or that good

Quote from reiusagi

Karina is vocally superior to Giselle she has support and range slightly weaker than Winter Giselle has little to no support and no range she can hit high notes but that doesn't mean they will be good or supported lol

It would be like saying Yeri is a better singer than Joy since she hit Wendy's bad boy notes but they weren't supported or that good

There’s no live content for Giselle to tell though. Her radio “singing/rapping” cuts were not singing nor was serious like the rest. She is the only member we still haven’t heard sing completely live in radio or variety shows. I do think if she actually try to show something she will surprise us but I will put Karina above her for obvious reasons.

Quote from Yumeku

There’s no live content for Giselle to tell though. Her radio “singing/rapping” cuts were not singing nor was serious like the rest. She is the only member we still haven’t heard sing completely live in radio or variety shows. I do think if she actually try to show something she will surprise us but I will put Karina above her for obvious reasons.

she sung in forever and she didn't have much range or support that has nothing to do with the amount of content because Winter has just as little content but we know she can support her voice and her vocal range ,Giselle is above average for a sub vocalist but regardless content her voice will still be the same unless she magically learns to support her voice she still will be lower than karina