As u can see Lisa songs being performing less well as time goes on, same for Jennie as her "anticipated" cmb didn't pass Lisa or hit1 in Korea
Now rose is using a very well liked western artist to chart high, but what will happen when she have to do all that alone? Will she chart lower like Jennie and Lisa did? The answer is yes bc I was right about lisa and Jennie underperforming and I will be right about anything else that come later
As u can see Lisa songs being performing less well as time goes on, same for Jennie as her "anticipated" cmb didn't pass Lisa or hit1 in Korea
Now rose is using a very well liked western artist to chart high, but what will happen when she have to do all that alone? Will she chart lower like Jennie and Lisa did? The answer is yes bc I was right about lisa and Jennie underperforming and I will be right about anything else that come later
I mean obv they will underperform compared BP because they have all started on their new channels, new labels and because it's solos the fandom is as divided as it can be... they will need to bring new fans for themselves and that will need more good releases and they will need time...
I mean obv they will underperform compared BP because they have all started on their new channels, new labels and because it's solos the fandom is as divided as it can be... they will need to bring new fans for themselves and that will need more good releases and they will need time...
The first single/comeback will always have the biggest hype and also the gap between the releases aren't long enough to build hype for the new release.
I think they will still have many long years ahead of them. They also have a good team that will help them navigate their career.
I mean obv they will underperform compared BP because they have all started on their new channels, new labels and because it's solos the fandom is as divided as it can be... they will need to bring new fans for themselves and that will need more good releases and they will need time...
I don't even think they are underperforming....lisa got her biggest debut in billboard hot 100 and UK chart just like Jennie got UK chart and Mantra is her best performing song in apple music. Even in spotify they are doing better than past release ( except money)
As u can see Lisa songs being performing less well as time goes on, same for Jennie as her "anticipated" cmb didn't pass Lisa or hit1 in Korea
Now rose is using a very well liked western artist to chart high, but what will happen when she have to do all that alone? Will she chart lower like Jennie and Lisa did? The answer is yes bc I was right about lisa and Jennie underperforming and I will be right about anything else that come later
Lisa’s Rockstar debuted global spotify higher than Lalisa and Money.
Then New woman debuted higher than Rockstar on global spotify.
Moonlit floor was promoted in B-side way without an MV.
Jennie’s Mantra is her biggest debut on global spotify.
It is hard though for an all-English song to hit no.1 in Korea. When other groups not named BTS and BP release an all-English song, it would be very hard to even chart on melon at all, let alone hitting top 5 on Melon as Mantra does.
Although Bruno Mars is huge, obviously he has never chart this high in Korean charts, so the good Korean charting of APT we are seeing is more from Rose’s power.
I mean obv they will underperform compared BP because they have all started on their new channels, new labels and because it's solos the fandom is as divided as it can be... they will need to bring new fans for themselves and that will need more good releases and they will need time...
The numbers are less, how is that gonna bring new fans? Their ig followers been moving to snail pace even tho they have drop so many songs, lisa and rosé solo in 2021 almost did nothing for 2022 bp numbers as they did around the same as 2020
The only thing that brought new fans was touring and it's not realistic to think that will happen with them wanting solo careers, their biggest solo hits were within bp (money, solo) and bp promoting again to gain news fans isn't going to happen
Display MoreLisa’s Rockstar debuted global spotify higher than Lalisa and Money.
Then New woman debuted higher than Rockstar on global spotify.
Moonlit floor was promoted in B-side way without an MV.
Jennie’s Mantra is her biggest debut on global spotify.
It is hard though for an all-English song to hit no.1 in Korea. When other groups not named BTS and BP release an all-English song, it would be very hard to even chart on melon at all, let alone hitting top 5 on Melon as Mantra does.
Although Bruno Mars is huge, obviously he has never chart this high in Korean charts, so the good Korean charting of APT we are seeing is more from Rose’s power.
But those songs don't even last 2 months on Spotify global, rockstar is out,new woman is out, Jennie already release u&me and it was all in English and it reach n1 unlike mantra, that didn't even have promo, Bruno Mars charted higher in yt artist Korea than rosé, if u think he doesn't affect her charting u are very naive
It's the same zico and Jennie duet reach n1 but Jennie very anticipated solo couldn't
But those songs don't even last 2 months on Spotify global, rockstar is out,new woman is out, Jennie already release u&me and it was all in English and it reach n1 unlike mantra, that didn't even have promo, Bruno Mars charted higher in yt artist Korea than rosé, if u think he doesn't affect her charting u are very naive
It's the same zico and Jennie duet reach n1 but Jennie very anticipated solo couldn't
Rockstar and New woman lasted long on global spotify chart if compared to other kpop acts, group or solo wise, excluding BTS and BTS’ members.
Jennie’s U & Me peaked no. 2 on Melon main chart, not no.1
It certainly also depends on the song.
This rather shows her consistency to chart high than underperforming.
Melon and YT korea are totally not the same listener segment.
And Bruno mars charting higher on artist chart is not surprising as Rose discopraphy had only 2 songs.
Rose OTG and Gone both charted in top 5 Melon. Any one song of Bruno charted top 5 Melon?
I said good Melon charting is more from Rose’s power, not all from Rose’s power.
Zico and Jennie collab is a Korean language song, how can we compare to all-English song on Melon chart?
The numbers are less, how is that gonna bring new fans? Their ig followers been moving to snail pace even tho they have drop so many songs, lisa and rosé solo in 2021 almost did nothing for 2022 bp numbers as they did around the same as 2020
The only thing that brought new fans was touring and it's not realistic to think that will happen with them wanting solo careers, their biggest solo hits were within bp (money, solo) and bp promoting again to gain news fans isn't going to happen
they had already hit huge numbers with IG so anything forward will likely move slower.
They have to have more performance where events are more general masses...
again, it's a slow process but they have to put in more work n reap less for sometime
They've been active for like almost a decade but barely have experimented or released anything, this is what keeping the hype. The minute they start releasing back to back music, their hype will die. I mean look at Lisa's solo career people already forgot the existence of new women when it's literally her best track till date.
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
