[enter-talk] OP shares her ideal debut lineup & concept for NMIXX and Babymonster - Knetz disagree

I thought the comments would be sweet & in defense of the correct lineups but no they're mostly harsh as usual. My bad

I don't agree with the lineup but both groups would've felt more balanced if they debuted as 5, especially nmixx.

Quote from bartkun

Because of Haewon's proportions, they won't be able to give off that "high-teen" vibe on stage

What's the issue with Haewon's proportions?

I do think they would do better as 5 member groups. But I'd leave out Bae and keep Lily for Nmixx, make them focus on more vocal RnB type songs (and Jinni isn't even part of the group anymore, so she doesn't need to be re-added).

I know Ruka is popular but I don't disagree with the OP there, she and Pharita add the least to BM. They have too many members who overlap in concept and appeal, so those two make sense to leave.

Quote from wsoet

What's the issue with Haewon's proportions?

There's no issue with her proportions, they just have a problem with their eyesight.

I agree with nmixx, but for BM switch Ruka with Rora. they have enough vocalists and Ruka is more interesting

Fuck you OP. Nmixx is fine

I think Nmixx is fine. I don’t believe they have filler members but their issue is music/ concept it’s like a mix between aespa and itzy but not done as good as either imo. I think a Snsd concept would suit them better. A more innocent/ cute concept with elements of girl crush/ sexy concept as they grow with age.

BM I feel like is too new to really say so far they’re ok i really like their music direction but don’t really remember the members

I think Nmixx should've debuted 1 year later as a 5 member gg with Lily, Haewon, Kyujin, Sullyoon and Jinni.

Bae never stood out to me and although I was rooting for Jiwoo before debut, she doesn't add anything new to the group.

About Baemon I would have left Rora and Pharita (or Chiquita) out.