Rolling Stone’s Top 100 Songs 2023 (Kpop at #’s 6, 47, 55 etc)

I'm surprised Seven wasn't higher and how high SVT is with Super.

NewJeans Get Up album was lauded as well:

Rolling Stone — 2nd EP “Get Up” (#33)

The New York Times (Jon Caramanica) — 2nd EP “Get Up” (#4)

Super Shy as the 6th best "song" of 2023... I'm speechless.

This is not even a real song for me, just a succession of tiktok hooks. There are like 20 seconds of verses in this "song".

The fact that it is a success commercially is totally understandable, even I somewhat enjoyed it a little, but the fact that music critics place it that high is mindblowing. Among all the songs that came out this year, rock, folk, metal, rap, indie pop, there are some real quality songs out there.

And they still chose "Super Shy" as the 6th best song. I can't take Rolling Stones seriously now.

I wonder what the criteria for getting listed is!

Quote from sonemariam

I wonder what the criteria for getting listed is!

Number 1 & 2 are tiktok hits so ig based on how trendy these songs are.

Wasnt for this list i would literally never find out about this, got top1 on spotify and billboard top5 lol, i rly dont keep up with trends

Gogo Twice and Jisoo !

Quote from KpopJop

you'd never heard of peso pluma???

I only found out about them today

I was happy to also see Rainy Days on the list. NewJeans and Agust D made the albums list too.

And yeah Rolling Stone staff probably has never looked at Korean charts in their life, nor should they lol.

Quote from KpopJop

NME puts Super Shy at #2 for 2023

I don’t make the rules, I just like what I see

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Super Shy? I'm buffled that OMG haven't been included in any list...

Pitchfork ranks ‘Super Shy’, by #NewJeans at #7 on their 100 best songs of 2023 ranking.

The 100 Best Songs of 2023

Featuring Ice Spice, Olivia Rodrigo, Lana Del Rey, Troye Sivan, Amaarae, NewJeans, and more

pitchfork.com

NME ranks Super Shy as #2 of their top 50 of 2023.

The 50 best songs of 2023

Embark on a sonic journey with our roundup of the 50 best songs of 2023. As this selection will prove, this year’s output was far from dull

www.nme.com

Pitchfork just ranked SuperShy #7 for the year. First K-pop song to ever make the list. Let the haters seethe.