Is Treasure The First Flop From Big4?

Genuinely asking…

BE311DE5-E696-47B5-ABC9-1D259E95EDB0.gif

If we include Hybe fromis is standing right there

Let's just say big 3 then yup! it's more sad cause yg bgs were all huge at one point then there's treasure

Stray Kids? Txt? Enhypen(are they even under hybe, idk)? They're all flops in SK at least. I've no idea how treasure is doing globally.

Txt, enhypen, iKon, Winner

every yg act except for BP

Quote from Be My æ (390)

Txt, enhypen, iKon, Winner

you did not just call winner a flop smh

Quote from Black Mamba's Pink Venom (513)

every yg act except for BP

this

they have 4 japanese members. its clear which market they're targetting and its working because they do really well in japan and are super popular

Treasure has good sales and similar digitals to a lot of the flop boygroups from SM, JYP etc.

nah every other 4th gen boygroup from other companies are just on the same level or slightly higher in korea.

Yes

I don't follow their sales but I hear about every bg but treasure. Where even are they?

Quote from Positive Anons Poster (271)

Stray Kids? Txt? Enhypen(are they even under hybe, idk)? They're all flops in SK at least. I've no idea how treasure is doing globally.

GOT7 also flopped in sk

Now is GG era. Except BB and BTS, every BG is not charting well digitally in SK. So it’s not only treasure.

All 4th gen bg flop in korea

Quote from Positive Anons Poster (271)

Stray Kids? Txt? Enhypen(are they even under hybe, idk)? They're all flops in SK at least. I've no idea how treasure is doing globally.

stray kids, txt, enhypen?? they’re not flops what r u talking about?

Quote from Escapee from YG Dungeon (78)

they have 4 japanese members. its clear which market they're targetting and its working because they do really well in japan and are super popular

are they more popular with txt, enhypen, and seventeen in japan? of those groups there's only 1 japanese member too

No, I think the first bona fide Big 4 flop is NMixx. And their follow-up sounds like the name of a German car manufacturer, so I don't hold strong hopes that they can be revived.

Quote from OP

stray kids, txt, enhypen?? they’re not flops what r u talking about?

People here must be dumb and thought you meant only korean charting, when there are multiple metrics out there.

Quote from Black Mamba's Pink Venom (513)

every yg act except for BP

people keep forgetting the point of the convo here. YG ACTS ARE FLOPS except for BP