Why do people always blame the company?

Quote from OldJeans

Of course, it's tiring. I never said it isn't. Just that it's not the main factor behind why female idols don't get to make music. You just made my post about something else entirely. It's not a discussion about how tiring or not making music is. But about how female idols are for the most part bared from making music. What you said was completely irrelevant.

if someone really have passion for making music, he/she should try to create the opportunity themselves if someone is not allowing them it means they are not good enough or they don't have the interest. Agency will choose the song that is the best since they are all for money and reputation in the industry. Soyeon's music is chosen because her music happens to be the best in Cube.

Because it's easier

Depends, when the decision is made by the company, i blame the company, when is a decision made by the idol i blame the idol. Lets say, that silly move in Girls choreo, i blame the company. Giselle saying the n-word, i blame the idol. Simple

Cuz my queens are perfect

Quote from OldJeans

Ah yes, so it's the female idols who don't try hard enough. It's their fault...not at all the misogynistic industry they work in.

so Cube is the only non misogynistic company? if so why they only let G-Idle to make their music? They had clc and has lightsum. Why those groups don't make their music? If u really think anyone can be succesful as G-dle and only barrier is companies not letting them write their music then cube as well let lightsum make their own music and get hit and other idols as well as can join cube so they can make their own music

Because in the music industry (Not even the idol industry, the music industry as a whole) Labels have an overwhelming amount of influence and say so on Artist activities

Is everything always on the label? No, but there's a hell of a lot that they are directly responsible for.

Also using Soyeon is a rather baffling example when it's been documented that Soyeon has had to fight to learn to produce and up until recently had to put her songs up against 3rd party songs every comeback for the title track.

Hell it's on record that Soyeon was the first female idol trainee at cube to learn Midi.

Miyeon mentioned that they get production training in YG and yet it's a struggle for any of BP to get song writing credits.

The company controls a lot, so the company gets blamed a lot.

Quote from quarkie

Even in Hollywood, managers and agents reject scripts that could weaken or harm their client's public standing. Just because she thought it was a good idea doesn't mean anything... that's the whole reason celebrities have these teams of people in place to help their careers. As the people responsible for her career and public standing, yes... it is YG's fault that they allowed it to happen even if she wanted to do it because they are supposed to be protecting her career from negative impact.

That's a weird take. If Jisoo wanted to do it too as a full adult, then it should be both at fault, not just YGE. If Jisoo didn't want to do it and YGE forced her, then I can see it being only YGE's fault.

People don't want to acknowledge when their bias messes up and it's easy to blame the company.

Quote from OldJeans

didn't say that at all. I said they messed up in the post. I think they are learning from their mistakes. they fucked up sure but they also did great with gidle. you're just putting words in my mouth because you want to argue.

just because G-Idle succeeding doesn't mean cube did good if cube was really good company lightsum would be doing way better

It is the company who ultimately puts a group there.

That's standard cult behaviour,

If things are going good, then the credit is all to the idol, if anything goes bad, then blame anyone and their aunt, but the idol.

Nothing new about it, just standard escapist behaviour.

Be it religion, poltics or Kpop.