Is Nayeon solo successful?

Unequivocally. Lest we forget the days when pretty much everyone said no twice member would do well solo. Now she is doing extremely well internationally and the songs continuing to rise is SK.

A good number of mouths kept running about how twice members would never be successful solo just a few weeks ago.

Comparing that to her to her 250k+ album sales and stellar charting is quite satisfying to see ngl

Quote from Serendipity2000

A good number of mouths kept running about how twice members would never be successful solo just a few weeks ago.

Comparing that to her to her 250k+ album sales and stellar charting is quite satisfying to see ngl

Emphasis on "stellar charting"

Success is always relative and often have a factor of timing into it.

We can all agree that charting can be dependent on who also came back that week.

Before anyone judge Pop!'s success on charting alone, I strongly suggest people first look into who Lim Young-woong is and how powerful the guy is in Korea. Once people fully understand that, only then can they judge Pop!'s charting right now. We're talking someone who can, and does, chart all 14 songs off his album at a time.

Nayeon's charting is actually more spectacular that it seems on the surface level.

Yeap

but that's not the question to be asked

the question to be asked is

what are the metrics to define whether a debut/comeback is successful...and the weightings one gives to each category

album sales (if it's an album)

K charting

spotify

YT

tiktok?

etc etc

Quote from selfmate

Yeap

but that's not the question to be asked

the question to be asked is

what are the metrics to define whether a debut/comeback is successful...and the weightings one gives to each category

album sales (if it's an album)

K charting

spotify

YT

tiktok?

etc etc

Display More

The only metric I care about.

If the songs were good.

Quote from fdblink

The only metric I care about.

If the songs were good.

Display Spoiler

SOOOLLLEEMMMMY!!! POP POP POP I WANT IT POP POP UH UH

and that's exactly the counterargument to every "success or not" thread

whether a song is successful or not shouldn't impact one's ability to like it or not like it as the case may be...

Yes. if her solo isn't successful then I don't want to know what an actual flop looks like.

Quote from selfmate

and that's exactly the counterargument to every "success or not" thread

whether a song is successful or not shouldn't impact one's ability to like it or not like it as the case may be...

To the quote book it goes

Quote from fdblink

To the quote book it goes

the good book says thou shall not worship false idols

Jesus obviously has never met kpop idols!!!

Absolutely. A superb solo debut song.

ABSOULUTELY

You can't call it exactly successful, It has seen a tier II success even by twice standard :)

Ofc it is

Yes she is very succesful, I liked Pop and her album songs

Yup

Nayeon making Thrice's life even more difficult