Both disappointed.
Posts by ForeverOnce2001
-
-
That would add up to how many albums Twice sold with their back catalog at that point on the year. It probably was a bad translation because no data shows that amount of sales, not even on Circle's sales charts.
Edit: I can't even find the video you're mentioning on Circle's Youtube page, so they might have deleted it for false numbers or the bad translation -
Display More
They sold nothing in Japan?
They sold nothing in the US?
What about the rest of the world.
Also for the love of God stop quoting me when you provide no evidence to back you up.
I have more important things to do than to reply to you.
P.S.: Once card still revoked.
The sales in Japan and Circle are already covered in Circle, except for digital albums, but there are usually no figures for that. If you have them, by all means share them.
You haven't provided any information. You don't even seem to know what is already included in circle lmao.
Born Pink sold about 2.6m in Circle and about 800,000 digital albums (pure) in China, which adds up to the number in the OP's thread. Digital albums in other countries arent' counted in Circle as they aren't physicals.
It's really basic to understand... -
-
It's at 1.121 million. What numbers are you making up? This is only pure album sales, meaning physical and digital copies. The Japanese sales are already included in circle and the US sales are already included in Circle, with the small amount of US digital sales unable to be verified since it's mixed with streaming. Either way, none of that adds up to 1.9.
Edit: It might be 1.9 worldwide units, including streaming. But then Aespa, G-Idle, and Blackpink would have much bigger numbers than now. The Album and Born Pink are around 7 and 5 million CSPC units. -
Between 1 and 2 total sales is only 1.1m? Aespa is more than that.
-
-
Makes perfect sense to me. 3 years, the 2020's decade so far.
Seems to be using Circle + verifiable digital sales in China based on the numbers adding up that way for BP and G-Idle. It most countries its hard to separate the digital album sales from the physical sales since the numbers are usually reported together. -
It's from 2020 according to that tweet and we're in 2023.
Also Twice sold hard in 2020. I could find sources but I can't be arsed.
It said 2020's meaning 2020's decade. The tweet is from 2023.
-
Display More
Sorry, but this is poorly researched.
Should The Album really have sold over 3 million albums? I've only seen numbers over 2 million so far.
Regarding Girls: Missing sales from Japan 65,555 and from the US 71,000. AESPA is said to have sold around 700,000 albums (is that true?) with Girls in China via a special offer.
This is clearly missing:
Twice Between 1&2: Korea 1,121,134, JPN: 54,244 and USA 199,000, is also the most successful girl group album in the USA.
K-pop is still far too unknown worldwide because many media such as e.g. MTV Europe intentionally ignores or even rejects many K-pop groups.
US copies and Japanese copies are part of the Korean Circle Chart physical sales already, unless they are digital albums. So the numbers for Girls and Twice are correct, unless they had digital album sales in China or the US.
Between 1&2 is not the most successful album in the USA. It sold the most physical copies in the USA in a single week, but The Album and Born Pink sold more total albums in units(what the US measures) in a single week, and more copies overall in album sales units. The Album is at 300k plus in the US in units and Born Pink I can't find numbers for but has charted consistently longer on the album charts. -
This list is very wrong. They don't list a source or methodology either.
Seems to add up for Blackpink and G-Idle if you include entire digital album downloads in China/US. Not units or streaming, just digital albums.
Since China increased album prices and regulated their industry, the Chinese sales are more in-line with international prices and are starting to be counted in things like this.
As for people mentioning "After Like" I think they didn't count single albums since in many countries they don't qualify as albums. -
Glad to see the worst and most biased moderator is gone.
-
-
-
I mean, 4minute's was basically the same but with less soul and worse raps.
-
and 2NE1 paved the way for 4Minute, doing the concept a lot better than either.
-
Great visuals but he song sounds bad.
-
I mean, BTS and TXT set the bar for live vocals pretty low.
I don't know if New Jeans are really much better than average considering that encore stage they struggled a bit with a very easy song. The member in the middle was good though.
Edit: If Seventeen counts, they are definitely leagues above. -
-
Despite her above average beauty, she never really stands out in the group as far as personality or talent. Without a big push for her to model or do cfs, she doesn't really shine except to those of us who are fans.
