Posts by Fluffers

I will only chime in to mention that one of their videos was comparing Han Sohee to Sulli and Goo hara.

far more than I expected.

Not a lot, but I expected to hear it zero times, but have heard multiple.

And not just the expected ones like Cupid or Dynamite which habe semi-regular rotation last year.

I've heard Blackpink (several songs) , New Jeans(It's specifically super shy like on 4 different occasions but still) and I-DLE and Red Velvet once each.

Never heard any boygroups besides BTS' english tracks (and Jungkook) though

Quote from DaisyTheGenuine

From what I saw, they were dragging plenty of female idols and all the top comments on most videos were saying they were going to end up like Sojang. I've, Aespa, Blackpink, LSF, Twice were all getting it.

It was everyone at the top. They had everyone from StayC to Iz*One (They started as a IZ*One Anti)

The channel has been nuked.

Do I think they're a copy?

No

When I think "This is just New Jeans"

I think of these

What I do think,.in regards to Illit, however is, is that what they are doing something that New Jeans could do.

They are plugged(heh) into a genre New Jean comfortably slot themselves in, even though they have yet to do it.

Another example

I don't think Dreamcatcher has actually done this type of Rock...

but if you told me they were having a comeback with something like it, I'd not even bat an eyelash.

Quote from WhyKnock

Twice debuted Oct 20 2015

GF's famous falling incident, which put it on the map, was on Oct 3 , 2015

Which led to this awkward situation

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

I think I commented at that time about this

Lovelyz - at that time an SM act, somewhat like what NMixx is to Twice now

Twice

GFriend , from a nugu company, run by a former manager of JYP

The very fact that Twice and GFriend were used in the same sentence would have been a big shock to Twice

Display More

Thanks for confirming my point.

Gfriend already had two hits by the time.Twice debuted

Bringing up Gfriend's slipping drama means nothing considering that me gustas tu was already in the top 10 a month before.

And again, ignoring Glass Bead, ehich was a hit 9 months before twice debut

Which was 6 months before JYP's reality show Sixteen even aired.

Quote from OnceMidzy4ever

In the parameters most kpop fans use ,popularity and money. Mamamoo can't beat BP or Twice. Is just like that. That's why Kpop is different from Sports. The most talented dont win overall. Meanwhile in Sports, the most talented groups and players are always on top.

Not sure why there's confusion over what you're saying.

If overall talent in all things was what would define success in kpop, the top groups would look incredibly different.

Aespa, Nmixx, and Babymonster would be the clear big 3. (If we're only speaking on vocal talent)

Like what you're saying is true with Mamamoo. Are they incredibly successful? Yes, but if it was sports, they'd be the Chicago Bulls in 95 and they clearly are not that in gen 3

Quote from selfmate

wait what?

I thought she was injured or sick or something

She did leave over being sick.

Anything else being said is people making shit up for drama.

Yknock, I know you were there when both those groups.debuted, andnI lnow youndidn't give a shit aboutneither back then cause you were busy getting drunk on the chatshire scandal..

But there's like a solid 3 months between twice's debut and Gfriend's second hit, not even their first.

From what I can see, it's actually a korean youtuber who streams to koreans.

It's likely a proxy thing that they're trying to get around

simplest ansser is a fal put between cloud and the rest of the band.

And while Cloud did produce a lot for Yerin, it wasn't everything and she's always been a songwriter.

Quote from thebadguy

Then how is aespa's drama listed here?

Because what is being referred to is a platform from before Aespa.even debuted.

How could Aespa's music on streaming sites.be lost if Aespa wasn't even formed to lose music

i wonder how Shinee felt when f(x) stole House from them.

If digitaos and sales of the year are the determining factor of the year.

Why is NewJeans from 2022 and npt 2023 if IVE had the best digital track record in 2022?

Quote from 3ne

Ooh, doesn't this mean Minisode 3 should have platinum certification now?

To be fair, I added the remixes to the regular one.

For the regular it's about 2k albums off, which should be about 3-4 days away

Quote from thebadguy

Can u combine these into the rankings that are in OP

Most of them are a distance away from the top 20 only ones relatively close is Aespa and IVE which would be in the top 40

Quote from hokiedood

Hasn't there been a rule put in place in China recently that restricts individuals from purchasing an album more than once? I thought I saw that somewhere.

That's a couple years old now, but yeah that's in place. But most of the albums up there are after that change.

Anything after July 2021 that applies.

And here are the 4th gen(Besides I-DLE who are already up there)

Aespa: drama - $598,689

IVE: I've Mine - $484,447.32

Le Sserafim: easy - $299,869

Itzy: kill my doubt - $280,750.68

TXT: temptation - $224,836.61

Itzy: born to be - $205,828

Enhypen: Orange Blood -$200,474.5

Enhypen: Dark Blood - $190,482.25

TXT: minisode 3: tomorrow - $140,790.29

Zerobaseone: youth with you - $154,098

TXT: freefall - $127,413

Treasure: reboot - $112,009.80

Quote from Jasmine_Waters

Don't see BTS BE or PROOF. Where are you getting these numbers from?

Outside the top 20.

BE would be #23 and PROOF would be #29 behind Baekhyun's minis and Love Yourself HER which would be #26