Posts by z1
-
-
dont take my list seriously lmao
i made it in 30 secs and probably missed some smh
Well some ppl got angry over it so I guess its too late. Im not that concerned abt the list tho, but to say feel special's Japan stats is everything is a stretch. In the grand scheme of things when compared to total international figures then we can see the difference. Japan is a big market no doubt, but they cant fight the world
-
International includes Japan, thats fair, but u cant say its bigger than ice cream. It had 100M cert for streams in Japan, if u add it into its total streams on yt+ spotify, it will still be lower than Ice Cream. And Ice Cream had over 1.3M downloads and multiple certs in China as well being of the biggest kpop songs there in 3rd gen, and even then Chinese streams aren't even included in YT or Spotify. I think both are similar level of hits at the very least tho and if one is included, its fair to say that the other shld be included as well bc of how poor they were in Korea
-
-
Wasn't TVXQ more physical era than download?
I thought its Physical + Downloads era but since Physicals arent applied here so i just said downloads but maybe they're even in an era where even downloads arent that prevalent
-
-
-
What stats? Ma’am charting was a thing after 2010. These are primarily older songs. How do I prove to you that I, like nearly all genz koreans, grew up listening to this and my parents listened to it because they were hits during their prime? Wtf you moron would you like a testimonial from koreans? Or would you like Panns angry reaction to telling them that we need “proof” to prove songs we all know? What do you need? A mf street interview?
Dude, if we go buy ur logic, we can just say that every song is a big hit because I feel like it is and because it is popular amongst my friends. Then I can just call any songs big hits because i feel like it is. There's a reason why charts and stats are there, they gather information abt a song from the whole country and they are for sure more accurate than some guy on a random website and his opinion on what are the most popular
-
its quite funny how someone claims something to be a fact yet has nothing to back it up other than thinking that he's opinion alone represents what songs are the most popular in the whole of korea.
How is it a fact if u cant even prove it?
-
Honestly right, the term national hit is only ever used here, I've actually not heard of the term anywhere else even on korean websites or by koreans.
Also, if the criteria for some of these songs are based on song performance, then some of them yall are arguing like PWF and TT are definitely similar size hits. One had insane longetivity esp in the top 50( Most of any gg) and the other had insane peak but had super bad longetivity. So if ppl want to take out PWF they'd btr take out TT as well.
AIIYL is like PWF but with even better longetivity and peak so it is not comparable to the 2 songs.
In no way is reaching #1 ever a requirement for a super big songs, this was clear as day. Everybody acknowledge the size of hits such as MGT, dolphin etc who never had the peak but had the longetivity to show for it.
-
Thread clearly made by someone who doesnt know the charts at all
-
Solo had almost 1M ULs which is more than any BP song besides D4 so don’t underestimate bp’s individual power
Solo actually had more ULs than D4
-
-
2019 is the most debatable tbh because in terms of concert sales Blackpink had more but Twice had more album sales. And Digitally Twice did better in korea + Japan but Blackpink did better every other platform internationally. So I'd say Blackpink has a slight win over Twice because of their digitals and also bc KTL charted incredibly internationally. The problem oso was that 2019 was not very strong digitally in korea for both Twice and Bp and the biggest gg digitally in korea was ITZY so neither dominated in korea digitally unlike some years like 2016 or 2020 where the domination was very clear.
2018 Blackpink had D4 and FY (Idk why everyone forgets abt FY its literally bigger than most title tracks) so technically they did better digitally in both korea and internationally. But their sales/concert doesnt compare to Twice so they cant be first.
Idek how Twice shldnt be on top for 2016 tbh. As big as rough was, it is nearly impossible to beat TT + CU
So GG side
2015- SNSD/GFRIEND (MGT released late July but it was an insane hit)
2016- TWICE
2017- TWICE
2018- TWICE
2019- BLACKPINK
2020- BLACKPINK
-
-
This list shouldn't count because in 5th/6th july 2020 there was major chart reform on MelOn.
you can see songs after chart reform:
External Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.Even b4 the chart reform its still top 5 so it makes no difference.
-
-
What's up guys👻
