What does Winter have that Karina doesn’t

    At first glance Karina definitely stands out the most, she is the prettiest and I felt like she had that IT factor and would instantly blow up

    I feel like the wrong member got popular even if I do like Winter. It’s another Taeyong vs Jaehyun where Taeyong is better in every way but for some reason Jaehyun has the upper hand


    She’s the most popular in Korea, Japan and China, her fancams always get 2x more views than the rest but when you watch them she’s just … dancing

    I dont find Winter entertaining to watch she’s BORING it baffles me seeing the other girls having 200 to 700k views and Winter nearly 3M on the Savage ones

    Karina is a better performer dancer and visual and her face actually moves. I think SM played their cards very very wrong

  • Moderator

    Approved the thread.

    Cuteness? I mean Karina herself said she is more sexy, maybe people are liking the cutest members these days?

    Or maybe its her vocals, I myself find that Winter's vocals are really amazing to listen to and combined with her visuals, etc she is the perfect idol to stan

    A stage name named after a season.

    i think SM played it well. Winter has a delicate appearance and is Taeyeon's second statue of talent and visual. Her target fans are teenagers, dominant in Korea and Japan. Karina has a sharp and strong appearance, most popular worldwide and sells aespa, because her fans are 20/30+. It's something like Jennie vs Lisa? The company has to cope and push each member to a different part of the world lmao.

    Confidence Winter seems like someone that knows what they want and gets it and it’s no surprise this is the trait of Capricorns whereas Karina comes across sweet and a people pleaser

    Quote from Cooked Cocoa & Mushroom Venison (787)

    Confidence Winter seems like someone that knows what they want and gets it and it’s no surprise this is the trait of Capricorns whereas Karina comes across sweet and a people pleaser

    Isn't it the other way around?karina has a tough and charismatic image whereas winter has a sweet,delicate and girl next door image that makes knetz like her.

    Quote from Poached Light Beer Lamb (254)

    i think SM played it well. Winter has a delicate appearance and is Taeyeon's second statue of talent and visual. Her target fans are teenagers, dominant in Korea and Japan. Karina has a sharp and strong appearance, most popular worldwide and sells aespa, because her fans are 20/30+. It's something like Jennie vs Lisa? The company has to cope and push each member to a different part of the world lmao.

    The comparisons are off. Lisa and Jennie have different vibes but pull the same fans across the same age ranges. Jennie is more popular in Korea because she is Korean but Lilies underestimate how the Korean GP also like Lisa. They only see the few instances of discrimination. Both girls have vibes that attract international fans

    winter feels relatable and friendly, kinda like how jimin is so popular in korea even if he’s not a visual like v or jk since he feels like someone you can become friends with. taeyong also feels unrelatable so he’s not as popular

    Winter is not the most popular member tho

    yeah Karina is prettier but Winter is a better dancer and performer

    but I don't get the hype of aespa as a whole they are still lacking for me

    Karina is pretty and all that but winter is clearly more talented. She has better dancing and singing skills and best stage presence in the group.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!

Register Yourself Login