Mnet seems like they want a legitimate international girl group this time

  • As someone who watched Produce 48, you could tell Mnet were just using the AKB48 girls for a small J-line. The original plan was to have 48 Koreans & 48 Japanese to make a 12 member group of 6 girls per side (hence why P48 had 96 trainees instead of 101, and why IZ*One was 12 instead of 11), but they dropped this concept


    Mnet also gave the K-Girls much more screentime, especially the Starship/Pledis/Yuehua line, while for the J-Girls it was pretty much…. Well the exact 3 that made it onto IZ*One. And for a short period Erii too. Even Jurina wasn’t shown much after the “Sakura vs Jurina” storyline, although she left the show early anyway


    Which was crazy cuz Mnet had stars like Miyu, Miho, Miu, Miru and the like, but continued to suppress their screentime. Especially Miyu cuz they knew that she was extremely popular on her own even without the push


    ——


    However I could honestly say, I don’t get that vibe from Mnet at all with Girls Planet 999


    The contestant lineup is an equal 33 per side. They made sure to have a rank system that would protect having an equal representation even after eliminations, and forced you to vote for a specific amount of Korean, Japanese, and Chinese girls


    As for the screentime, there’s no favoritism. And it looks like they do have their eyes on just as many non-Korean girls as they do Korean girls, such as Yurina, Hikaru, Mashiro, Ayana, Xiaoting, Ruiqi, Yaning, Cai Bing, Hsienwei, and more


    Even with the 3 centers, they push Xiaoting & Hikaru a lot more than they do Dayeon


    Mnet did confirm that there is no nationality limit towards the final lineup, meaning it won’t be mandatory for it to be 3x3x3


    I do however believe they want something similar. Which leads me to believe that this lineup having more non Koreans than Koreans isn’t something they’re against, and possibly something they support


    Is it risky? Perhaps. But it is experimental and innovative, and would look good if they turn out to be a success. Besides we saw what happened with TO1 with To Be World Klass. They had the whole global group concept, ended up with an all Korean lineup, and where are they now


    With the top 9 being 3 Koreans 3 Japanese & 3 Chinese twice now, it does seem like that is what they actually want. However because of that, I am sure they’ll either get that or something similar, like 4 Koreans 3 Japanese or 2 Chinese


    I do think they fear it being 6 Koreans & the rest foreigners, because it would be a typical Kpop girl group instead this new style of a Kpop girl group. Because nowadays, just throwing 1 Japanese & Chinese member isn’t gonna stand out, I could name like 10 groups since the 3rd Gen that pulled that off


    Into1 made a beautiful lineup from Produce Camp which had a similar concept to Girls Planet 999 although with just any foreigners


    And now they got 6 Chinese, 3 Japanese, and 2 Thai members


    External Content youtu.be
    Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
    Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.


    Personally, I am not be necessarily against more Koreans as long as there is more than just 1 Japanese & Chinese member. Although I can say, I’d be more interested in an Into1 type group more than an IZ*One type group


    I trust we’ll get a good lineup either way

  • With all of this said, I really hope Mnet does NOT rig the lineup to fit their dream team


    I’d much rather they just keep the voting restrictions so that everyone knows what they’re signing up for, than to tell everyone that they’re free to vote for anyone regardless and yet still tamper with the lineup


    Not only is it a slap in the face to the fans who were told they can vote for whoever, and yet there was a planned lineup afterall, but it hurts the trainees too. The rigged out members who had their dreams stolen from them, and the rigged in members who gotta live with the guilt that wasn’t their fault

  • Yes and I hope Mnet doesn’t cave in & create a traditional Kpop girl group anyway


    I gained a lot of interest in this group & show because of the multinational concept. A group that actually shows that diversity would be much better than a group with the exact Korean to Foreigner ratio, or even worse one if it’s like 7K1C1J

  • Agree with you but I still feel like Japanese trainees get a bit sidelined compared to Korean & Chinese trainees. That might be cultural though - maybe the Japanese girls just do not "generate" the same amount of screentime-worthy drama as K & C girls, lol. The only girls I remember from the J-line are Mashiro, Yurina, Hikaru, May & Shana (the latter after The Eve mostly), also Ririka & Miu due to Nizi Project, but Miu's screentime is virtually non-existent, while Ririka briefly got thumbs up from masters in YoY and then disappeared again. I fear that if this continues, then when it is going to come down to 1-pick voting not restricted to groups, the Japanese girls will tank heavily in rankings.


    Btw, INTO1 is even more multicultural - 5 Chinese, 1 Chinese-American, 2 Japanese, 1 Japanese-American (mixed), 1 Thai, 1 Thai-German (mixed).

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!