XG performance at Coachella wasn’t live!!!!

XG is definitely not singing live. That’s what happens when hate trains are formed when an actual live stage happens. Lip syncing is safer, for artists, than singing live because of brainless fans

It's almost like David is still here with us

That was an incredibly boring argument to read. Anyways..

It's the similar to how I feel about LE SSERAFIM. I already know both groups can sing well and live. One bad performance/one lip synced performance will not change my viewpoint.

I think an apology is underway from you too, Taemin-Identity

I know Hinata for sure was not singing live. (last week)

last night was better, although big portions were still lip-singing. still a good show, fav coachella gg performance so far.

I mean OP is entitled to their opinion just like how they should extend the courtesy when people point out Taemin’s very obviously regressing vocal skills.

go watch their performance last night at coachella and honestly tell me if they're lip synching the entire performance.

Mmmm, you have another video about this? The one you posted was deleted.

Ok, about this one, we can see in some parts the girls sing but dont have the mic close to their mouths. I'm always suspicious when the live presentations sound exactly like the studio version, not a note change, not a mistake, all clean. There is not struggle in their voices when they are moving and singing. Great singers with years of experience have these issues, but no these young singers?

Mmmm, my opinion is this is not live. Is a prerecorded audio that pretends to sound live.

Kpop group can't sing live. Are people really shocked by this? The vocal quality has only gone down over the years. Anyway much rather they do this than subject people to what comes out their mouths that they think is singing. If you can't sing don't

Quote from foreveraespaaa

Tbh people need to accept barely anyone sings live anymore! It’s either a very loud backtrack and they sing 1 or 2 words or it’s all prerecorded to sound live

We can’t actually expect people to dance with choreos and think they’re also going to sing live I know XG have great vocals so personally it doesn’t bother me! They probably just wanted to focus on their dance and stage presence

And even when idols or local pop stars "sing live", it's all autotuned. Either in realtime for the live audience, or in post production before the performances are uploaded to Youtube, or both.

Every single Kpop "It's live" Youtube channel is not true live REAL vocals. They've all been autotuned. I feel bad when i read all the stan comments in these channels bragging about their faves "live" vocals.

This dude Wings of Pegasus has a great channel exposing all of this using software that detects autotune. Even mah girl Morissette has had her vocals autotuned in post production .

Her rendition of Andra Day's Rise Up is the greatest unautotuned pop performance on Youtube tbh, the second song O Holy Night was proven to be autotuned.

pasted-from-clipboard.png