Who seems to be the greatest victim of Rose's APT? IU, aespa, Illit or BTS?

Quote from One-and-only

frankly speaking it's blackpink, once blackpink members evolve more into their own identity they don't need blackpink name anymore it maybe good for members but it's a little disappointment for fans that invest in group activities.

oh i wanna see it

I wanna see how they keep the numbers by themselves bc none of them was brave enough to be upfront about the group being over to keep the name up

Quote from killingtime1934

oh i wanna see it

I wanna see how they keep the numbers by themselves bc none of them was brave enough to be upfront about the group being over to keep the name up

why are you so sure? What if you ended up being wrong and regret you wasted all your time hating them when you could be enjoying each era? Aren’t you supposed to be happy they are releasing more music than with YG lol.

The losers may be Chapelle Roan, Sabrina Carpenter etc., and none of the acts you have listed.

Rose's success will matter more outside Korea and IU/Illit/Aespa are still highly Korea focused.

BTS - SolUnits (1 member subunit when their group is still active are not soloists), like other BP-SolUnits are the true competition to Rose.

So it is Lisa, Jennie, Jungkook who are the most affected by Rose' success, ONLY if it were a zero sum game where winner takes all. It is not.

So it is WhyKnock who is most affected.

Quote from JUSTVIBING

why are you so sure? What if you ended up being wrong and regret you wasted all your time hating them when you could be enjoying each era? Aren’t you supposed to be happy they are releasing more music than with YG lol.

bc I havent been wrong

their debut been mediocre, all falling a day after, just being help by ft, collabs or duets (the wkn song doing better than u&1 and mantra, zico song doing better than mantra, rose leeching of bruno)

they are doing nothing but proving me right

and this is all while the hype of their fist solo happen

what are they gonna do when that is over?

and on top of that the music is ASS

karina song being better than all of bp solos

It’s Gdragon. He’s comeback is gonna get buried with APT

aespa is the biggest victim since they couldve charted more higher if it wasnt for rose comeback

What will WhyKnock do, if a collaboration of some sort happens between Rose and IU?

Quote from WhyKnock

That will be a surrender of IU to Rose however I don't think Rose will do it since she has transcended Korea and does not have to curry IU's favor anymore.

Depends, if they sing mostly in Korean, then it "filial duty" surrender. But if Rose gets IU to sing in English.. then maybe,

English is ok, as long as it is not gibberish that IU had to sing the last time.

biggest victim will be rose if she's not able to reproduce the same success with her own solo stuff

but right now it's aespa obviously they completely screwed up the timing

and not just because of APT, with their own solos too

Quote from nevermindmejin

I think it’s Jennie.. because her collab with The Weeknd, who has the highest Spotify listeners, and from a highly talked about tv series- did not get even a quarter of the attention like Rose/Bruno’s collab is getting Lisa too (might throw this in lol)

ps- if Rose got BP their first number 1 on BBHot100, congrats to her!! Hope BP can taste that sweet victory too

that collab just happened and it blew up because the song got viral but it was not like the most anticipated collab . I think her acting debut was the one that was more anticpated at least for blinks. it's good it it did well but I feel a real collab was the one she had with Zico imo. Having said that I feel most kpop artists might be victims of Rose's ATP. I doubt any song will get as popular now.

Quote from killingtime1934

bc I havent been wrong

their debut been mediocre, all falling a day after, just being help by ft, collabs or duets (the wkn song doing better than u&1 and mantra, zico song doing better than mantra, rose leeching of bruno)

they are doing nothing but proving me right

and this is all while the hype of their fist solo happen

what are they gonna do when that is over?

and on top of that the music is ASS

karina song being better than all of bp solos

Display More

Bruno mars also benefits from this collab it's not only Rose. Not to long ago he was losing popularity and having a younger audience and kpop fans it's good for him as well marketing wise. It's mutual even if it's a good opportunity for her.

she is not leeching this song is more her style ( something she wouldn't released before) and it's extremely catchy he just happen to be a popular western artist. if the song was bad she wouldn't pull those numbers. Same case with Zico and Jennie. Not only Jennie had more input but a lot of lines it was a proper collab.

Jennie is doing well with Mantra in Korea for example it's all on her.

You are being very simple minded if anything this proves their higher reach to be able to collab with more artists. Many of them have been open about wanting to have collaborations with the girls.

Quote from WhyKnock

Lee Jieun did cover an English song

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

so she will probably sing in English with Rose if the latter permits.

Covers are not the standard.

You haven't answered what if the collab song is mostly Korean?

How will you twist the story then.

Quote from Panpriyah-lice

No, in fact, Rosé even helps Jennie and Lisa's new song climb a new rank.

They aren’t victims, they are the ones who benefit the most from the success of Rosé. It's a kind of free promo for all BP members

that’s a lie right there. Moonlit floor had climbed back to top 15 before APT release

Quote from WhyKnock

Even if that happens, if it fails to chart in Hot 100 or Spotify, it will just pass as a one time event

That does not matter, what matters is that SK and IU will remain relevant even by that narrow definition you demand.