idk why but bg stans keep taking out their own securities about enlistment on SHINee

idk why but bg stans keep taking out their own securities about enlistment on SHINee

Lets get real, it will be hard/impossible for any other bg to manage their enlistment time as well as SHINee. Taemin promoted them well when Onew/Key/Minho were enlisted and they are promoting Taemin now. During their 6 month together they had 3 comebacks, 2 concerts and 2 free online events. There is so much security and comforts among the members and the fandom knowing very well we are all in it together and on the same page.

Ever since 2019 kpopicks have been singing gloom over SHINee's enlistment. I still remember the akp users in 2019 who said SHINee will never release anything together. Looking at how things turned out for the groups they stan, they should have kept their mouth shut then. The fact they still think they can have negative opinion on how SHINee managed their enlistment era is fucking funny.

Quote from xx-jenn-xx

I don't understand why they are complaining Taemin did a lot and kept the name SHINee alive for everyone, they came back and released some banger music as a group, now each of them doing the things they want and succeeding. like i don't understand why they are complaining.

All the Taemin merch going out and the posts about his kitty lol

they are complaining bc they know their group doesnt have what SHINee members have among each other

Quote from Ramasson

shinee did super well with enlisting :)

I still think it is just the smartest thing for all members to enlist at the same time

2 year hiatus and nothing is along time in kpop

alot of people move on or at the very least it cramps the progress of the group

SHINee didnt lose any fans and go even more people interested in them

Quote from xx-jenn-xx

SHINee is a family, more family than anything. And even has a casual listener I can see this. They would be there for each other over anything SM would do. I can picture Key telling SM to fuck off if they mistreat them. Given the unbreakable bond they have and how strong they became with Jonghyun going to heaven as an angel, there's nothing out there that can tear them apart. At the end of the day some groups may not get along, some just go home, but SHINee is still family. I've watched alot because of Sammi, read alot etc. and I can say that I see something with them that you don't see in most groups. People can be jealous but this kind of thing is not something that just develops instantly.

just like Taemin said, one day they might not be coworkers but they will always be family for each other

Quote from Ramasson

It is only 1,5 years which is not a lot for mid or very famous groups anymore, especially if they are older.

You can also preproduce a lot of content and for example publish a single or dvd in the middle. BTS should definitely consider this.

It might be less time now, but when SHINee enlisted it was 22-20 month and it is more for Taemin now that he transferred to public service.

Alot of groups get hate for releasing things after enlistment

anyway my point is other fandoms have no right speaking on SHINee when no other bg have managed themselves during enlistment as well as them

Quote from xx-jenn-xx

ahh okay thanks for explaining. I assumed they could do like some videos or post photos but as far as like recording an album or a dvd or anything like that WHILE enlisted they can't. If their company releases merch that's a different story. but at least they are able to still update fans. Like Noir's Junyong posts photos alll the time

I mean there is the legal side but also from PR point of view

Knetz really hate on those who release stuff

Even Baekhyun had to deleted stuff I believe

Quote from xx-jenn-xx

omg i remember that, they threw a fit that some shit was uploaded on youtube then they took it all down made no sense at all

I think it's either legal gray area or too much backlash from public

Quote from xx-jenn-xx

that's extremely dumb to me, why would people complain that they are getting some content from a member they are missing...unless it was jealous anti's

Yeah I don't think it was fans but people

Which other group is gonna literally unite in a music show?