BTS' PROOF album would sell 10M copies if released in a 'regular' Kpop pricing

  • it costs as much as butter album for me and it contains so many songs

    thats why!

    'Butter' is actually expensive for single album. For kpop albums number of songs don't matter. It's about contents. 'Butter' single CD has more content than regular k-pop album that's why it is more costly than even full length k-pop albums.


    I think be: generated as much money as MOTS:7 despite selling half of it.


    But I don’t understand this charts it’s based on USD, Won? No way an albums selling 2Millions can only make 10M

    The index is not revenue generated. The index is to tell how much the sales would be if all albums were priced similarly.

    Let's take Nayeon's album for example. 'Proof' has 11 times the sales of 'IM NAYEON' but 'Proof' index is 33 times that of 'IM NAYEON'. That means if both were priced similarly then 'Proof' would have sold 33 times more than 'IM NAYEON' when it has actually sold only 11 times just because of the price difference.

    Hanteo actually shows revenue as well. I remember seeing 'Proof' having $86m revenue when it was at 2.8m sales on Hanteo.

  • The index is not revenue generated. The index is to tell how much the sales would be if all albums were priced similarly.

    Let's take Nayeon's album for example. 'Proof' has 11 times the sales of 'IM NAYEON' but 'Proof' index is 33 times that of 'IM NAYEON'. That means if both were priced similarly then 'Proof' would have sold 33 times more than 'IM NAYEON' when it has actually sold only 11 times just because of the price difference.

    Hanteo actually shows revenue as well. I remember seeing 'Proof' having $86m revenue when it was at 2.8m sales on Hanteo.

    You explained it well.


    It's exactly $96,339,649.7 with the price of 51.9 USD & 17 USD on weverse global. And if we're basing it on Hanteo numbers with the month of June & let's say 50% of sales are from standard ver then the other half from compact version. That's the baseline but it's more than that because when it was first released the prices were 55 USD & 21 USD until HYBE changed it. Just dk how many albums were sold during that time. Either way it's probably just a small gap like up to 100M USD or probably more lol.


    I think be: generated as much money as MOTS:7 despite selling half of it.


    Yes. I estimated that MOTS:7 generated somewhere between 100M USD - 105M USD, then BE 'Deluxe' edition generated 110M - 120M USD. Can't compute the exact amount due to shipments from other countries, but that's the ballpark. So yes, BE did not only generated as much money as M7, it edges it a bit due to the price tag.

  • Why did you write an essay when I already said it’ll increase but you can’t directly convert exactly like the way it’s in the OP lol. Also literally everyone knows everything you wrote here lol. Common knowledge. What I said wasn’t this.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!