To be honest Rolling stone Korean isn't really wrong about Jisoo

    no matter who wrote the article, they are telling the truth


    https://mobile.twitter.com/spi…tatus/1546518050509164544
    she is the least talented of the group and her dancing/singing didn't improve that much , the only reason she made it into BP ,is because of her face


    Miyeon and Jinni are 100x times more talented than her and if she was in another group, she would be a sub-vocalist

    But I guess Blinks just wanna save her honor

  • Moderator

    Approved the thread.

    What if they weren’t technically wrong? This isn’t supposed to be a article to critique them, it was just plain unnecessary period

    Quote from Steamed Chestnuts & Venison (609)

    No Miyeon can actually sing

    so can Jisoo if she is given songs that fit her voice despite the backhanded compliment the music critic complimented her lower range


    External Content www.youtube.com
    Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
    Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

    I disagree, Jisoo has shown she can rap, Jisoo can sing beautifully and has a pretty face. Just because the compony want to push other members more, mistreating her more than the other members, resulting in less fans compared with her peers doesn't mean she doesn't have any talent.


    Miyeon and jinni are very talented as well, but Blackpink wouldn't be Blackpink without Jisoo. Her charm and her tone of voice is her signature thing. Jisoo deserves better.

    Quote from Steamed Chestnuts & Venison (609)

    No Miyeon can actually sing

    She’s not technically outstanding tbh (and I say this as someone who likes her voice lot) and as a performer, I would say Jisoo fits into Blackpink better.


    Anyways, the point of Blinks being mad is because that is so unnecessary. The article isn’t to critique the group, it’s actually quite literally the opposite, so I don’t understand why the writer felt the need to be shady and xenophobic.

    Idk who told y'all she's lead vocalist. I started stanning them during pwf era and we all knew jennie was the lead vocalist then I took a break from staning and come back to see jisoo is the lead vocalist I'm confused. Can someone explain.??

    Jisoo sings Better than jinni, is this a way to promote jinni ? And is also considered prettier by k beauty stabdsrdsv

    Quote from Deep-Fried Corn Studded DooDoo (363)

    She’s not technically outstanding tbh (and I say this as someone who likes her voice lot) and as a performer, I would say Jisoo fits into Blackpink better.


    Anyways, the point of Blinks being mad is because that is so unnecessary. The article isn’t to critique the group, it’s actually quite literally the opposite, so I don’t understand why the writer felt the need to be shady and xenophobic.

    yeah the point isn't if he is right or wrong but how unnecessary was to write about that

    Quote from DooDoo Glazed Pork Chops (555)

    Take her part in Pretty Savage and tell hip-hop twitter she's the new rapper on the block. Their feedback will help you forget all about the RS article.

    for a kpop vocalist she didn't do bad obviously she isn't a rapper. I don't think any kpop rapper will be praised in hip hop twitter lol Geez, people take everything way too seriously

    It's true but damn that was ruthless by rolling stone lmao.

    Quote from DooDoo Glazed Pork Chops (555)

    Take her part in Pretty Savage and tell hip-hop twitter she's the new rapper on the block. Their feedback will help you forget all about the RS article.

    I listen to N.W.A and Eminem all the time, I know what rap sounds like, I didn't say she was a rapper like Cheetah, I said she can rap, she rapped Jennie's part in D4 LIVE and her rap in pretty savage isn't bad for a vocalist.


    That's real talent

    Even if she isn't top vocalist or dancer, articles shouldn't be written like this. It's not appropriate. Yoona from snsd barely can sing or rap, but no one wrote article about her that way? Or any other weak vocalist or rapper. I can tell you hundreds of idols who are there for just their visuals but they don't get articles like this. Do they? No. Sakura can barely sing, wasn't really getting any big lines on previous groups but she's top idol, did anyone said smth like that about her on official articles? Ofc not.

    Plus Jisoo is a good vocalist, maybe not taeyeon level but it's not necessary, she pulls of what she sings perfectly. She proved many times she is amazing live. Not some of you discrediting her again.

    Quote from OP

    another dumb idea from yg so fans can leave them alone

    Jennie is the only lead vocalist

    it has always been Rosé and Jisoo vocals and Jennie and Lisa rap but Jennie is so well rounded that she is also part of the vocal line.

    even if what they said isn't wrong but what was the point of that RS article btw?

    like who hurted them that they had to release an article shading BP unprovoked?

    Quote from OP

    stop your delululu, facts speak for themselves

    Jisoo has never sung the major parts in their songs and never will. mark my words


    yg only gave position for soyas so they can handle something

    ok Jennie akgae

    Miyeon is not really better than jisoo at dance or singing and jisoo is much more charismatic so nope, bp lost nothing there

    Miyeon isn't a top vocalist but she'd definitely be the main vocalist in BP

    comparing average singers with average singers to determine who's better lol. for any other groups if they had BP talent, they'll be label as average, but for BP themselves, people saying theyre great. settling for the bare minimum and pedestal it as great smh

    Quote from DooDoo Glazed Pork Chops (555)

    Take her part in Pretty Savage and tell hip-hop twitter she's the new rapper on the block. Their feedback will help you forget all about the RS article.


    Wut? Have you seen the state of local "rap"? It's pathetic. They're a disgrace to the true rappers of the 20th century. Kpop rap is 10000x better than the mumbling incomprehensible mush mouthed autotuned nonsense coming out these days.

    lol, since you can't saying on the main without being called an anti you have to resort to anon, isn't it op? we already called you out now when twice is coming and we shade them don't act like you didn't start it

    Quote from Cooked Cocoa & Mushroom Venison (682)

    comparing average singers with average singers to determine who's better lol. for any other groups if they had BP talent, they'll be label as average, but for BP themselves, people saying theyre great. settling for the bare minimum and pedestal it as great smh

    Bruh, it was OP who started this shitshow.

    I always thought that Rose is the vocalist, Jennie the rapper, Lisa the dancer and Soyaa the visual. But all have other attributes in each of them too (like Lisa can rap and sing with good visual etc).

  • This thread contains one more post that have been hidden for guests, please register yourself or login to continue reading.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!

Register Yourself Login