Posts by BEG4DAWIN

Nevermind

This is because 'rolling' does not count as a 2021 song right?

So the Korean GP prefers dolphin to the other B sides of the current album?

pasted-from-clipboard.png

Bona and Luda look totally different when they smile, and their noses are different.

PIXY

You should create an artist thread for them.

Quote from FSXP

I think this is hard to determine because some people are going off recent hits while others are going off now as in a state of consistency.

Personally, I wouldn’t put Brave Girls on the list. They just had their breakout hit with Rollin & We Ride is riding off that hype. I would say you’ll need at least 2 more comebacks to really know if they are a digital force. Plus, I think TWICE should make an appearance because they have more hits than misses (and MMM and RV have some misses too that Twice didn’t have until FS/ICSM)

Personally, I think state of consistency matters more for now so

1. BLACKPINK

2/3/4. Twice/Mamamoo/Red Velvet (RV hasn’t had a comeback in a while but Psycho was massive, Mamamoo has some consistency and Twice obviously does well with majority of their promoted material so I think they’re interchangeable at the moment.)

4. Oh My Girl

5. Itzy

Brave Girls will land high after a time of digital consistency among comebacks.

Display More

Yes I think time frames are very important.

Brave girls may go away as suddenly just as they came up, we do not know, but we can not deny that their songs are smashing all kinds of digital records.

So if we are doing currently, as in say the last 365 days, then it is hard to argue that any Girl Group has been as successful as Brave girls digitally, B.P. is the only group that can be argued may be superior/equal.

If we say right now! as in 2021, then no doubt it is brave girls #1.

So

1. Brave girls (Who may become Momoland for all we know, but they are smashing 2021 so far)

2. BlackPink (Mostly because of Rose solo, has BP released a song this year?, I know that they are the only girl group capable of matching Brave girls)

3. O.M.G, Dun Dun Dance is #2 on the I-chart, matching Rose from BP, I guess this proves they are not 1 hit wonders.

No clue about anyone else, I guess Mamammo, Itzy, G-idle or Twice. for the other spots.

Again this is 2021 only.

pasted-from-clipboard.png

https://www.instiz.net/spage/8

Quote from omnimorphism

Total Digital Points from the top 200 of the 2020 Yearly Gaon Digital Chart (I'm to lazy to sum over all months and even more over all weeks)

1. Oh My Girl: 1,178,182,476
2. Blackpink: 1,098,736,404
3. Twice: 764,530,363
4. Itzy: 718,605,154
5. Red Velvet: 693,910,356
6. MAMAMOO: 669,122,542

If anyone wants a more correct month by month or even week by week, feel free to do it. Or ask massive for the numbers.

Edit: more accurate version from the top 1000.

2020 Girl Group Cumulative Digital Points

• 1. BlackPink - 1,433,455,863 (12 songs)
• 2. Oh My Girl - 1,251,102,188 (5 songs)
• 3. Mamamoo - 758,368,792 (5 songs)
• 4. Twice - 753,299,906 (8 songs)
• 5. ITZY - 740,875,128 (4 songs)
• 6. Red Velvet - 721,952,443 (5 songs)
• 7. IZ*ONE - 651,676,087 (22 songs)
• 8. (G)I-DLE - 432,268,348 (4 songs)

Display More

I am surprised at no Brave girls, 2 songs are smashing the charts, perhaps the time frame is too short as of now, I would imagine eventually they will be on the top 5 or top 3 on the list.

Edit: Nevenmind, I see that it is a 2020 list.

I will let my self out.

Maybe she said no to plastic surgery.

Quote from itiswhatitisss

Not just 4th gen groups tbh, many 3rd gen groups started switching to GC concepts once D4 blew up. I do think it was blatantly obvious back then, but these days groups are adding their own unique spin to it which is nice.

4Minute for example, they copied BP.

ok, ok, 4M is second Gen.

In a recent interview for WJSN the black, the interviewer referred to them as a 13 member group (at least it was translated that way)

They did not correct him.

She is one of the better ones for sure.

Quote from Selynn

Their music is very different. I personally have never heard Blackpink do the video game music style. Aespa debut song was like the Mortal Combat movie soundtrack. Their styles are luxurious and they also do a girlcrush concept. These two similarities are enough for you to compare. Don't be so visually focused.

4 members and the luxurious style are the big things IMO.

Social media 'influencer' is the hype right now, and that is how BP and Aespa are sold to the public.

It is very smart.

The Video game aspect does differentiate the 2 (among other things)

All groups have influences, even first generation, they were influenced by idol groups from the west with Korean styling.

I know I joke about 2NE1 2.0 or in this case 2NE1 3.0, but even 2NE1 was probably influenced by a combination of prior groups.

Not bad, they can sell, the next goal (for the group) is to chart.

If they chart 2 or more times in the top of the I-chart.

Selling 100K is also a good one.

WJSN is probably not nugu anymore.

I have said it before.

Have some type of elimination show to save 1 or 2 CLC girls.

It is no 'non-stop' but it will do well.

Yoo Jaesuk creating hits for everyone that goes on his show (and they just played their song).

Here is how they are charting early in the morning Korean time

pasted-from-clipboard.png