Posts by QueenMaknae27
-
-
She killed it!
-
-
It’s not a coincidence that this is being talked about bc she is having success. Sigh… haters
-
-
Good for the queen to comeback at the same stage
-
NJZ would have and will one day
It is more likely to happen that a 6th gen would tour there first than them having cb or even a tour
-
I know you meant this wholeheartedly Yamaflop
-
-
-
Display More
So, in short, you agree with me.
And what do you think I asked other than "which girl group is the most impactful in K-Pop history"?
SNSD is sweeping every a.i. I ask.
Display Morewell i also did it and here is the answer of chatgpt
Hopefully we can put to rest the Chatgpt debate now
And I already provided my chatgpt answer. In the end, AI still is not reliable in this age
-
Display More
How have they made it bigger? Legitimately. How? What did substantive change did they bring to the industry that remotely compares to a group like SNSD, who set a new and still ever-present standard all girl groups use today? You still have provided zero arguments detailing BLACKPINK's impact and why it's GREATER than SNSD's.
You're just being a cop-out artist with the generic "SNSD in Korea! BP internationally!", which contradicts the entire essence and effect of the Hallyu Wave.
BLACKPINK is currently the most popular girl group today, but they are NOT the most impactful girl group of all time. Anyone who knows their K-Pop would agree. Korea certainly agrees. Japan certainly agrees.
Arrogant Blinks in the West will argue otherwise.
And now I will smack ALL of you with another A.I. kill shot
Yama... I already did say in the earlier reply basing by my own definition. Just like you are with your own definition. And you are not agreeing with it because it correlates with success and records.
Are you even reading my replies?? No, seriously
And I also used chatgpt that you love so much showing what I typed unlike you who is hiding it. And much accurate answer from gpt than what you posted now.|
Unity, Visual, and powerful performances? That's what GPT came up with? I bet you just typed and didn't proofread it. LOL
I'd agree with Korea but Japan? Now you are erasing Kara's existence. Come on now -
Since you like using AI, here you go
Screenshot 2025-04-01 050634.pngThere is NO argument when it comes to BTS and BP. BTS is MUCH bigger and completely overshadow BP in every conceivable way.
I never said BP was bigger than BTS tho. Since you like the what if game, if SNSD is in this era, they will also be overshadowed by BTS. BP is not the biggest group. BP is the biggest GIRL GROUP. There is a difference. The same way SNSD in their era
BLACKPINK can't even reliably outpace NJZ in the West, based on the numbers you all care about so much. And they don't even have the biggest song. That would be Fifty Fifty.
They do have touring, but hey guess what? Twice has that too. They fill stadiums too. They would've done so WITHOUT BP in the picture too. Or are you now going to say people only became Onces because of BP too? Wonder how Onces would feel about that.
It's hard to keep an argument with you if you keep changing lanes. That one user was right
You said success and records does not define impact. And here you are now.
You called and admitted that BP is the biggest girl group in the world. I won't have to argue anything since you already know their position in the 3rd generation until now
Again, I will say this. Let's stay on the main topic Yama Look, BTS is just insult to injury. Even if I don't bring them up, I don't see or feel any of this impact from BLACKPINK.
Them being C Listers in the U.S. doesn't come close to matching the legacy and impact of SNSD and the Hallyu Wave they helped usher in.
Less talented 2NE1 isn't on that level. They do pull big numbers though, so I'm fine giving them the most successful girl group, even if that is somewhat a function of the times.
That is your personal opinion and that is okay. Go for it. It's not like you're changing and convincing me anyway
SNSD played a big part in spearheading Hallyu Wave, and BP is now playing a big part of making it bigger -
It's just a fact. Blinks always talk up BP's achievements in the West as if they're comparable to BTS's, which are on a completely different scale. It's unfortunate for BP, but they are completely overshadowed as a group by BTS, and if anything they benefitted tremendously from the doors BTS opened.
If you are going to compare it to BTS, there is a gap but if you are going to compare it to the rest of ggs, there is a big gap
Same way to SNSD, If we gonna include bgs, SNSD is not the biggest group in their generation and be overshadowed as wellYou should stayed with the first sentence but not surprised you found another way to discredit them. The same argument you are going for SNSD has come back to bite you. They are the standard. Your faves was even influenced by that.
I mean could you blame BP for setting the standard so high that other ggs can't really reach them???
We are just going back that we have different pov of what impact is -
You are creating your own rules again to fit your own narrative.
Are we now going to a different lane? I thought we are talking about ggs?
If you are going to the route of entirety of KPOP and include the bgs, then some of SNSD's impact would be diminished as well.
And this thing that BP only benefitted bcs of BTS, in some ways true but not entirely. Before BTS started promoting in the West, BP already charted in the Hot Bubble w/o any promotions and being a less than 1 year old group showing their true potential in the West
Let' stay on topic Yama -
Is that "someone" me? I mentioned Gangnam Style in a different thread.
Nope. I believe his name was Yama or something?
-
I'm gatekeeping this sentence
-
Display More
That is a simplistic, binary and fallacious take though. The Hallyu Wave is famous because of what it did OUTSIDE of Korea.
I talked to ChatGTP too.
The Hallyu wave, also known as the "Korean Wave," refers to the global spread of South Korean culture, entertainment, and lifestyle, which has gained immense popularity worldwide. This cultural phenomenon began in the late 1990s and early 2000s, driven by South Korean music (especially K-pop), television dramas, films, fashion, and food.
So enough of the "SNSD only made an impact in Korea!" arguments. K-Pop is what it is today because of the Hallyu Wave, and SNSD was at the forefront leading the way.
I can do what you did too.
THIS IS THEIR LEGACY. THIS IS THEIR IMPACT.
BLACKPINK cannot compare.
I never said SNSD has no impact outside of Korea. BP has more by my own standards just like you are sticking with yours
You didn't show me what you typed on chatgpt tho? :curisng:
Can't believe our discussion already reached chatgpt. What's next, twitter?? -
That's impact, I mean just success!!! Legendary!!!
Wrong thread Mona
-
If I make it statistical, then you would just look it as success not impact which we do have a different pov to begin with
I already made my case from the start same as selfmate
BP outside, SNSD Korea. My final answerChatgpt? How about this?
LMAAAOO!!!
Screenshot 2025-04-01 025320.pngYour memory fails you. SNSD was doing Genie in 2009, along with other classic hit songs and concepts.
Sure, but not to be inspired by SNSD. Completely different concepts
SNSD is absolutely the MJ of K-Pop Girl Groups. The parallels are obvious. I already detailed it earlier. Keep it up, QueenBoomer87
This bish! I am still young!!
