In Korea have 3rd gen groups shown more longevity than 2nd gen charting/ gp wise?

Discuss

3rd gen is showing better longevity accross the board to be honest.

Charting 2 gen lasted much longer and with a much wider set of groups.

Snsd, 2NE1, Sistar, WG, T-ara, Apink, Girls Day etc all managed to chart high for few years (SNSD 10th anniversary was a flop by their standards but they outcharted all JYP ggs in the last few years). Nowadays it’s mainly BP and occasionally Red Velvet and that’s it. 2 gen ggs were clearly better at charting.

Bgs excluding BTS who are in another league it’s arguably not that better or worse because in 2 Gen only a a few bgs like Suju, Shinee, 2pm, 2am etc could chart decently and the main one was BigBang and for a while Beast. in 3 gen it’s only been BTS and previous Exo. everyone else got like 1 or 2 hits here and there same as 2 gen.

Public, 2 gen very easily. They charted better overall + they appeared much more frequently on tv. Some idols even got their own shows like SNSD, Suju, Shinee etc. 3 gen barely even on tv, mainly the occasional running man and knowing bros.

have they? 2nd gen bgs after military chart better than alot of them

2 gen has better longevity 3 gen biggest act is bts and bts sure will keep 1 even on the 4 gen

No. 3rd gen is weak in Korea. The groups are lucky bts gave them a boost in international level

BTS and BP carrying them

3rd Gen sucks overall. Except for BTS and the ggs there aren’t any digimons. At least in 2nd Gen we had more groups charting especially for the bgs.

BTS rules