Txt have the best discography in kpop so why are they not #1?

discuss

No they don't

I agree but..

they aren't #2 or #3 or #4 either when they have the best discography in kpop. No other artist matches their best discography in kpop and still they aren't the most successful kpop artist even with the best discography in kpop.

Discuss

Do they?

when did they have the best discography well if then that's thanks to hybe producers i guess

it takes lots of other factors to be top group

Lack of IT factor

i have no idea why the #1 group is the #1 group as it is

They have low amount of charisma IMO, look at their Dynamite cover, now compare it to BTS ''perfect man'' cover back in 2015 when they were a 2 years old group and see the gigantic difference in charisma and IT factorness.

Their discography isn't even that good, it's just overpraised because everything else is lacking

why is this in anons??? just setting txt up for no reason once again. and they do have the best discography in terms of versatility and listenable music

they’re too “all rounder” and lack a strong point. they’re all skilled but none stand out in rap, dance or stage presence. even their vibe are not clear either. take enhypen, sunoo, jungwon is cute; sunghoon, heeseung is cold, jay/niki is sharp,… their vibes are very clear so they draw in hard core fans, txt don’t stand out individually so they may have casual listeners but not hardcore fans.

They don't their shit music is the best only in your delusional mind

Having a good discography does not equal popularity, in all pop music popularity is dependent on many other factors then music.

Their music really isn't that good, it's spiced up with hybe aesthetics but is pretty generic and oftentimes forgettable, that's why it kinda appeals to a lot of people; but those people don't actually get passionate about them. In addition TXT aren't very engaging performers, and despite being touted as "all-rounders" by their fans, they're only good at dance and mediocre at best at everything else.

Quote from Stir-Fried Southern-Style Bear (391)

Their music really isn't that good, it's spiced up with hybe aesthetics but is pretty generic and oftentimes forgettable, that's why it kinda appeals to a lot of people; but those people don't actually get passionate about them. In addition TXT aren't very engaging performers, and despite being touted as "all-rounders" by their fans, they're only good at dance and mediocre at best at everything else.

I like a few of their songs but most are bland.

you can't be serious lmao

HYBE seems to think TXT are the next coming of one direction but can't do 1D with a group of dozens especially vocally.

Quote from Stir-Fried Southern-Style Bear (391)

Their music really isn't that good, it's spiced up with hybe aesthetics but is pretty generic and oftentimes forgettable, that's why it kinda appeals to a lot of people; but those people don't actually get passionate about them. In addition TXT aren't very engaging performers, and despite being touted as "all-rounders" by their fans, they're only good at dance and mediocre at best at everything else.

Bladphemy. They have the best discography in kpop

because