Non-MOA opinion about TXT " Eternity" Album

Thank you for listening.

The way you described Eternally was perfect! I freaked out when first time I heard it, it has to be the weirdest song they made and no, I didn’t liked it at first. I fell in love after listening it a lot of times. First the slow part I loved…then the fast part…then I started to enjoy the no transition between the parts lol I would love them singing it in live but it would be a total riot.

Fairy of shampoo is amazing. Originally it was an old song and they really did a good job at keeping the old vibe but adding the modern flavour to it. Yeonjun wrote the rap part to it, it wasn’t originally in the song.

Maze in the mirror was a grower for me. I didn’t think I will like it. Lol

I put this here it’s up to you if you wanna watch it or not. This is my favorite clip of Yeonjun and the closest we will get to live Eterally. Also shows what a clown he is.

We have very different taste...lulz

I think I would tie this with Freeze tbh but it's really hard to rank their albums...Puma is my fave TXT song so it raises the value of this album a lot for me

1. Puma

2. Maze in the Mirror

3. Fairy of Shampoo

4. Can't You See Me?

5. Eternally

6. Drama

Quote from dryheat

We have very different taste...lulz

I think I would tie this with Freeze tbh but it's really hard to rank their albums...Puma is my fave TXT song so it raises the value of this album a lot for me

1. Puma

2. Maze in the Mirror

3. Fairy of Shampoo

4. Can't You See Me?

5. Eternally

6. Drama

Display More

Yeah I agree with the Freeze tie part. I calmed down after the first day and I have to say it’s fighting for the favorite album title with Eternity.

My ranking is similar to yours

1. CYSM

2. Fairy of shampoo

3. Maze in the mirror

4.Puma

5.Eternally

6. Drama

Quote from SooYoung

the i loved the slow part and i thought it was a really cute ballad

but the no build up transition to a more upbeat part really took me by surprise and it didn't help that i was driving while listening to the song

I knew it that it was an old song, the instru gave me some old vibe, it really gave me feelings that it a song who would fit perfectly in a cabaret

also the way they were singing some part, it really remind me the way some old singer use to sing

Display More

Lmao listening Eternally while driving must have been a shock. That song should come with a manual for first time listeners.

Least favorite album besides Freeze (tho i need more time to listen to it). CYSM took awhile to grow on me also. But overall only added Puma, CYSM, and Drama to library.

Quote from SooYoung

:OO

Puma TXT best song ??????????????????????

OK let me go edit my comment about your thread " rate my txt top songs"

after hearing this i can't give you more than 4/10 sorry

Yes it's my fave TXT song

I can't help your tastebuds

Quote from SooYoung

Btw there was a member if i remember clearly in fairy of shampoo in the chorus who was going into higher notes while singing, in the second part of the second chorus

Who is it ?????

Soobin

He does most the falsetto stuff

Edit: actually wait...gimme a timestamp to be sure

Quote from SooYoung

Btw there was a member if i remember clearly in fairy of shampoo in the chorus who was going into higher notes while singing

Who is it ?????

Lemme listen quickly. It was most likely Taehyun but I wanna make sure I’m not lying…

Yes, Taehyun. He did it in live too.

Here is the original song if anybody curious.

I want this on my playlist but apple doesn’t have it.

Quote from dryheat

Soobin

He does most the falsetto stuff

I thought OP meant in the end the very high note. That was Taehyun.

Quote from crazydoll86

I thought OP meant in the end the very high note. That was Taehyun.

Idk what they mean so i need a timestamp

i wasn’t too big on puma at first too but i started appreciating it more after the mv and performance dropped! these things change your perspective a lot. the song has an extremely deep meaning too. it’s based on a real story of a puma escaping a zoo in korea and instead of capturing it, they shot it down and killed it. it sparked a huge outrage. they’ve interpreted this story in their own way. something like moving out to the real word but facing lots of hate and criticism. you’ve already given the whole album a listen and that’s already so nice of you but if you do have the time, i think you should check these out too!! i can promise you that it’s a grower

also, this album places fourth for me out of the five albums txt have released. i’m fond of the b-sides especially the bridge in mitm and the entire fairy of shampoo song, but the title track just wasn’t for me lol. i feel like a flop for saying this but it’s my least favorite txt song ever. including all their b-sides too

TDC: Eternity is definetely a good album, though it isn't their best album of them for me personally, it's their 3rd best album. Eventhough I don't think it's their strongest; it has Drama, which I think is their best B-side track in their whole discography. There's just something about this song that I love, it's funkiness, the energy, and also the choreo. They also really seemed to enjoy their performance when they performed this song. Their smiles and expressions seemed so natural, they really enjoyed themselves on this particular stage, it's definetely one of their best performances.

Song Ranking:

Drama

Fairy of Shampoo

Can't you see me

Maze in the mirror

Eternally

Puma

Maze in the Mirror forgettable

Quote from bumble-bunny

Maze in the Mirror forgettable

Tragic since one of my fave songs from them

Quote from dryheat

Tragic since one of my fave songs from them

Quote from bumble-bunny

Maze in the Mirror forgettable

Same. Maze in the mirror is beautiful.