Mnet Kingdom is getting hate for bringing rookies as experts for 3rd round evaluation

So far the evaluators' names that were mentioned are SJ - Donghae and Shindong, Yoon Mirae, BDC, some of Weeekly, Tribe and Loona members.

Apparently, it was done in Queendom as well so not all are hating on them having rookies to judge the 3rd round (part 1) evaluation but some fans are pissed about it.

Quote from SooYoung

i mean they learn for years how to dance, sing, perform, act etc.....

even if they just debuted, that doesn't change the fact that they have years of training and experience in this field

so they can judge them on real criteria

I see no issue as well but they're mad that rookies will judge BTOB and iKON members' perfs as they're big sunbaes.

Quote from keaji

So the experts were revealed? I didn't see anything about that. That's interesting.

These experts are for this collab round only, first and second round experts are not revealed yet

Quote from bartkun

then what did they expect? No one has so much money to bring all top idols from 1st and 2nd gen to evaluate... lol

what did they expect that SNSD, Big Bang, and others will be evaluating performances?

even will say more they could bring much more known and popular artists - rappers who are known from SMTM but then Knetz will be angry "what do they know about dance" etc. :-D

somehow when in 'Good Girl', Weki Meki was one of the groups which were grading performances it wasn't a problem for someone like Cheetah...

Display More

I guess they wanted some professional/experienced dancers/choreographers, singers, rappers, trainers etc to be part of the evaluation team, it doesn't matter if they're not idols to them.

Quote from icyruios

They brought trainees in for Queendom evaluation as well iirc for like the first week? Literally trainees they haven't even debuted

I remember because there were cuts from trainees in the audience. I don't get what's the big issue

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

pasted-from-clipboard.png

Display More

Yup, that's why I don't see the issue as well, since they're basically copying/pasting what they did in Queendom