Who is currently the biggest; Lisa vs Jennie vs Rose

Quote from monalisalove

Rosé didn't achieve more as a soloist than Jennie and Lisa, they have more songs that are extremely well known and successful.

The biggest physical sale goes to Jisoo.

Biggest hitS it's either Jennie or Lisa

Biggest song Rosé

Biggest fandom still Lisa

Jisoo just had fanmeetings in Asia that surpassed 100k attendance, Lisa did 5 too that had 67k like ??

Fashion wise Jisoo brings the best numbers for her brand and then Jennie or Lisa and then Rosé

Every one of them have metrics that put them almost in the same level and then it goes down to what you consider as the most important to decide, but no blink here discredited Rosé like you are saying.

And Fenty didn't lie, she corrected your wrong take.

Display More

Dawg..

Idk success as a soloist imo isn't only limited to hit songs. Rosé getting featured in TIME, F1 soundtrack, Billboard top 10 etc is more impressive to me and also surpasses anything J and L have done. There was a time when these two were more successful and even now you can say Jennie has more hit songs as well as the biggest solo song but the rest are just very irrelevant metrics. Rosé and Jennie haven't done a proper tour like Lisa and Jisoo, pointless to compare that.

That's it. If you still don't understand what I am trying to say then don't quote. Just leave this conversation as it is cuz I ain't spending any more energy fighting with you.

Quote from OopsEncoreMoi

IMG_4909.jpeg

disagree with this. More people know Lisa due to White Lotus. That show is huge and a lot of people know the Mook cahracter. However, people that follow that show are most likely unaware she's a popstar

Quote from vzal

Dawg..

Idk success as a soloist imo isn't only limited to hit songs. Rosé getting featured in TIME, F1 soundtrack, Billboard top 10 etc is more impressive to me and also surpasses anything J and L have done. There was a time when these two were more successful and even now you can say Jennie has more hit songs as well as the biggest solo song but the rest are just very irrelevant metrics. Rosé and Jennie haven't done a proper tour like Lisa and Jisoo, pointless to compare that.

That's it. If you still don't understand what I am trying to say then don't quote. Just leave this conversation as it is cuz I ain't spending any more energy fighting with you.

And yes, bc you are using the criterias you think matter the most like any other user here, but just you got all defensive over people opinions but yeah, it's not like your super points will make others change their opinions.

Quote from vzal

But Blinks would rather throw her under the bus to hype up mediocre idols like Jennie or Lisa who are neither more talented nor more successful than her.

Mediocre ? who tf are you calling mediocre

Just so you know, the so-called mediocre idols you keep trashing also helped build BP — the same place your talented girl came from.

Sit down, you two-bit solo stan

Quote from vzal

This forum downplays Rosé so much.. first she was labeled the flop member despite OTG doing better than Lalisa. Then y'all credited all of APT's success to Bruno as if Rosé wasn't the one who came up with the song. And now just blatantly lying when she's proven herself as a soloist with TTTE and her album tracks. Y'all don't deserve her. If any other idol achieved the same thing she did with APT. and her album, their fans wouldn't shut up about it. But Blinks would rather throw her under the bus to hype up mediocre idols like Jennie or Lisa who are neither more talented nor more successful than hér.

Girl… you can’t be taking when you’ve spent a lot f your time in this forum downplaying bp and giving Rosie back handed compliments until you decided to token stan her…

lisa because i say so

Intresting... this is really hard to guage to be honest...

When Rockstar came out it was Lisa because she had Blinks and Lisa stans with her. When APT came out it was Rosé but Rosé not only broke the kpop barrier she also captured a big majority of the west, enough for them push the song surpassing PSY's Gangnam style which is feat in itself... She also was everywhere with general public of Korea...

The downside is Rosé music style doesn't cater to such wide audience so it didn't really translate to her album numbers... her album did great but surely not to the level of APT...

Then came Jennie's Mantra which really did well but her album solidified her western audience and she has undying support from her Korean fans who are not even necessarily kpop fans... Her fashion also brings in a huge audience and they are pretty loyal to her. She had the best reach in terms of album release and music likeability across the board compared the all members.

With Lisa sadly it dependent on Blinks support... She has the largest solo fandom who are really dedicated and also undying support from Thailand but the only (main) changing factor were unfortunately BLINKERS... Compare the numbers to Rockstar when there was neither Rosé or Jennie's release announced to post when Rose and Jennie started releasing/ announced their release... You can now see the divide in the fandom... Thailand supports the other 3 members (obv not to extent of Lisa) but Korea is non existence to her... Another huge factor to impact her was her Chinese fans, her second biggest supports but after the Crazy Horse scandal Lisa was banned and that affected her a lot... Plus the hate campaign which was also fuelled by Blinks which they never do to the other girls... Imagine core fandom hating on you and boycotting your release?????

But then came The White Lotus and now the amount of new fans she has pulled who are curious about Lisa... cementing that in Coachella, alter ego is finally shining... Lisa also have captured a lot of Top fashion moments post YG and being highlighted for her fashion.

I say all 3 members are well known/ biggest in different criterias... their next solo comeback will actually cement their status... But this Blackpink comeback is crucial and hope it's done right.

Jisoo is a suprise packet... Its difficult to actually judge her influence... I need a 15 songs album to actually compare the album aspect but in terms of fashion Jennie and Lisa have always been the highlights but then came Rosé with YSL and then Jisoo with Dior and Jisoo with Dior having max impact was truly a suprise... She gets good support from Korean public and Blinks are super supportive with her music release and esp the international fandom is also a fan of her acting and support her acting projects... She also has massive support from Chinese fans so she is pretty up there but difficult to place her amongst the other 3 because it keeps changing...

I mean now you see why Blackpink is BLACKPINK...