Yunjin or Jennie: Who is the better vocalist?
- Go to Best Answer
-
-
-
That's bc liking vocals are literally personal taste. You can be the best vocalist according to critics, if I don't feel your music I won't care about your vocals.
Jennie is an amazing vocalist imo and her album just cemented this more. She sounds good.
And Yunjin in lsfrm isn't her at her best from what I saw.
-
That's bc liking vocals are literally personal taste. You can be the best vocalist according to critics, if I don't feel your music I won't care about your vocals.
Jennie is an amazing vocalist imo and her album just cemented this more. She sounds good.
And what exactly did you see?
That one coachella clip?
Anyways, I'm not asking what vocals you like more.
-
-
-
And that's your opinion
-
And that's a fact
-
Evil, fake ediiiit
-
-
Evil, fake ediiiit
All is fair in vocals and war
-
I don't know if I should engage with this thread, if it's serious or maybe it's a bait for the fanwars
But I think there's a few reasons why it's hard to compare them as vocalists.
Is Yunjin classicaly trained? She seems to be and afaik classical singing is so different from modern "pop" singing. She sounds great in the clips where she's doing classical singing and I also liked the clip from Lee Mujin's Service, but imo she's struggling a bit during this Weverse Con performance and I saw some clips online where she struggled while performing with her group.
Jennie on the other hand is a full blown kpop singer but also singing never was her main focus, because she's a rapper too. From what I remember from my days as a blink, her singing was usually powerful and she was stable while performing live but it is hard to compare her to someone trained in classical singing, who was probably trained a lot in the aspects that kpop idols don't often focus on that much. In Blackpink I feel like they focused a lot on sounding original and stylised their voices in a certain way while classical singers obviously learn the proper technique , musicality etc. (I am not one, but this is from what I know, as I used to study with such singer at the uni)
So we could argue that perhaps Yunjin is a better vocalist but Jennie is a better kpop singer.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Yunjin isn't an opera singer.
She IS a classically trained singer, though, who would be equipped to sing opera with a little more advanced training but I'm pretty the only opera she's sung is Carmen Habanera.
She could probably be considered more of a musical theater singer than an opera singer, though.
-
-
Opera singing and pop singing are different. Yunjin's using different skills for each. You gotta compare her pop singing to Jennie's pop singing. I think Yunjin was born with a larger vocal range and more power. But, I think Jennie uses what she was born with better than Yunjin. Jennie has better control, more stability, and better expression. She understands her strengths and leans into them. Yunjin has potential, but she hasn't surpassed Jennie.
On top of all this, Jennie has more star power - it's just something magnetic about her. She has that natural swag. I love Yunjin too, but I'm ngl her hyping up the Coachella crowd was a little cringe (tho iconic).
External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy. -
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
