LE SSERAFIM had a great vocal performance, but nobody said anything

I watched both performances!

They performed really well

But it is 95%+ lip singing

I hear them but the backtrack is still loud. So no lyp sinc but not a big vocal performance either. I say this as their fan. BUT. I do think they are one of the best performers in kpop and I do care about that. They are scarily good at rocking the stage.

On another note. Is it possible that the performace was truly live and the youtube update was edited to seem perfect? Because I think I heard somewhere that sometimes they do that with live performances.

I think it’s hard to praise them for this now when HYBE stated they can’t sing live and some past performances fans thought we’re live were not Lsf are great performers though which imo is more important nowadays than singing

Hybe use double backtrack?

I wouldn't know it was lipsync if not for their slip tbh

Anyway, they are great performers, their fans love them for it. It's fine to do what they do best

Quote from Taemin-Identity

I watched both performances!

They performed really well

But it is 95%+ lip singing

Thank God, I wasn't the one I said that.

This is anything but great. It's OKAY, nothing special, but from them, it's better. They're still struggling with their own songs, because neither of them suits their range. At least, my ears are not bleeding.

Quote from lidora

On another note. Is it possible that the performace was truly live and the youtube update was edited to seem perfect? Because I think I heard somewhere that sometimes they do that with live performances.

It's all on the companies. HYBE ask them to fix some problems, use 2 or even 3 layers of backing track, but that's all. I mean, the actual live performance, not the video. In the video editing they only removed the noises from the crowd and etc.

To see the difference! Not the vocals, obviously, because that wouldn't be fair, but it's easy to hear the difference between the editing and sound engineering. They didn't even remove when Hwasa was heavily breathing.

This is lipsync + pre recorded live.