BABYMONSTER - “FOREVER” Band LIVE Concert

Live Queens

Rami ahyeon vocals at the end

It's OFFICIAL! It's LIVE doing a better job with Babymon than YG ever did! I didn't like the original, but the live-band version is 10 times better! The girls deserve so much better than YG!

I mean, how on Earth a Youtube channel can do a better job than a billionaire company? Release Babymon YG and give them to another agency. You're done and dusted!

lol it is clearly not live, as 90% of other artists’ performances on its live. Last time it was also not live with sheesh. Only time I’ve seen live performance is by Ailee. Other artists’ performances including Sm artists have been pre recorded, lip synced, or heavily edited and autotuned.

Rami and Ahyeon ❤

Quote from Taemin-Identity

lol it is clearly not live, as 90% of other artists’ performances on its live. Last time it was also not live with sheesh. Only time I’ve seen live performance is by Ailee. Other artists’ performances including Sm artists have been pre recorded, lip synced, or heavily edited and autotuned.

Please for the love of God, if you don't know what these terms mean, don't use it!

LIVE singing can be pre-recorded as well. It's Live don't use autotune, this is just a simple mic and volume correction, and yes they usually remove the heavy breathing as well. EVERYONE who was invited to It's Live or Killing Voice sang live, didn't do any lip sync!

You want to hear unedited versions? I don't think it would please your ear, even if it was done by the best vocal group.

This is how a RAW version sounds like!

David33 Lol As someone who sings and performs all his life and has minor in music, and listens to many artists from all over the world(not just kpop) I can distinguish which is live and which is not. Even my fave group Shinee didn’t sing live with “Hard” cb on its live. As for babymomster some parts don’t even match with their mouths. It is extremely polished, compressed and I can’t even hear their breath(where in music shows we at least can hear breathing). Some little parts were live tho. My guess is artists sing live and producers just put the studio or polished version over it and we can hear some live parts(because they are not perfectly on pitch or they didn’t compress and polish that part). Also on Killing voice they sing live and I didn’t say a thing about killing voice

Quote from David33

Please for the love of God, if you don't know what these terms mean, don't use it!

LIVE singing can be pre-recorded as well. It's Live don't use autotune, this is just a simple mic and volume correction, and yes they usually remove the heavy breathing as well. EVERYONE who was invited to It's Live or Killing Voice sang live, didn't do any lip sync!

You want to hear unedited versions? I don't think it would please your ear, even if it was done by the best vocal group.

This is how a RAW version sounds like!

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Display More

Quote from Taemin-Identity

David33 Lol As someone who sings and performs all his life and has minor in music, and listens to many artists from all over the world(not just kpop) I can distinguish which is live and which is not. Even my fave group Shinee didn’t sing live with “Hard” cb on its live. As for babymomster some parts don’t even match with their mouths. It is extremely polished, compressed and I can’t even hear their breath(where in music shows we at least can hear breathing). Some little parts were live tho. My guess is artists sing live and producers just put the studio or polished version over it and we can hear some live parts(because they are not perfectly on pitch or they didn’t compress and polish that part). Also on Killing voice they sing live and I didn’t say a thing about killing voice

Well, I edit videos like this for 20 years and I work in the industry, not as a musician, but still. Just because they sound clean and looks like their lip movements don't match, doesn't mean it's not live, and it's not their fault. They sing live, but as I said, editors HAVE to remove the minor mistakes in their voice, even their breaths. That's why it sounds like they don't sing live.

For the record, I don't like doing this either, but that's the standard, everyone want to hear studio quality. They're removing background voice and with that, they're removing some vocals as well. That's why it sounds like they're using autotune.

Then what’s the point of lts live when they edit out everything. I’m not saying they should put out unedited version, but not to the point where it sounds like an AI cover or cheap studio version. BTW I love to listen to raw versions most of the time, since I can feel the emotion and liveliness of the song

Quote from David33

Well, I edit videos like this for 20 years and I work in the industry, not as a musician, but still. Just because they sound clean and looks like their lip movements don't match, doesn't mean it's not live, and it's not their fault. They sing live, but as I said, editors HAVE to remove the minor mistakes in their voice, even their breaths. That's why it sounds like they don't sing live.

For the record, I don't like doing this either, but that's the standard, everyone want to hear studio quality. They're removing background voice and with that, they're removing some vocals as well. That's why it sounds like they're using autotune.

the band sounds horrible but it's probably because of the song

Quote from Taemin-Identity

Then what’s the point of lts live when they edit out everything. I’m not saying they should put out unedited version, but not to the point where it sounds like an AI cover or cheap studio version. BTW I love to listen to raw versions most of the time, since I can feel the emotion and liveliness of the song

Don't be so dramatic, this is anything like an AI cover LOL.😂

This is what most people want, that's why producers ask the editors to do. At least, this is still live, unlike Music Show performances, (not the Encores). Now, those 99% of the time are lip sync.

Talented girlies, I LOVE this version.

Ahyeon, Rami

Pharita is always so effortless in her singing. Chiquita is improving as well.

I loved the performance. And them saying it was a summer song surprised me.

Maybe it's because the MV did not have an outdoor setting, so I just felt like it was a retro vibe. But, okay, Forever is a summer song!