Catgirls review of ILLIT pt.2 - So what are they missing?

it's just their debut though maybe I'll wait for their comeback and finalize my thoughts they might change to dark concept since their MV kinda have dark undertones on the last part... we'll see

it's really a shame though I want to see Iroha, Yunah, Moka and Minju in a teen crush or girl crush concept since that iswhere most of their strength lies.

like icb Belift wasted this potential just because easy listening songs is a trend now

Iroha

Yunah

Moka

Minju

exactly they shldve done a girl crush concept where literally everyone except wonhee would fit in PERFECTLY... the problem w this is that iroha and yunah seem 'off'

like their stage presence during some of their songs seems kinda forced and unnatural altho WE KNOW that all the girls can deliver... its just that they dont show it

The only thing missing is big eyes. New jeans have bigger eyes

Quote from Fearnot-Once

the problem w this is that iroha and yunah seem 'off'

ify seeing their debut stage I kinda feel disappointed ngl I know they tried their best to suit the concept but from someone who watched R U Next I just knew they could have delivered more... it's not the best song nor concept for them to show their potential and talent... we'll see on their next stages

i kinda agree.

Yunah and Iroha shine more in teen girl crush type. You can check videos those other users put above.

And Minju..she really has unique tone vocal that unfortunately didnt show up in this debut.

Check she in :

About Moka actually she can fit in any genre.

But they just debuted. They can be better in the future.

Thanks for the thread. Finally I can rant what's been on my mind after watching their stages ytd.

- I dislike the MV, I feel they're trying too hard to match New Jeans's debut vibe but failed. This is about aesthetics, not musically.

- They truly don't look very natural performing especially Minju and Yunah. For some reasons, their RUNext performances were better than their debut, ironically. Their choreography looks so lazy and uninspired (again, RUNext choreography was better).

- Title track is good but this overly girly childish concept isn't really my vibe. This song is getting old fast. Their b-sdes aren't good enough for me.

- I still don't understand why the company suddenly become unhealthily obsessed with Wonhee and chose her to be their center and made the concept circling around her vibe while ignoring other girls' strong points.

- Iroha's bang is a crime. They picked her because of her dance skill but there's no way in hell she could show off her skills with this girly concept and weird choreography.

- Youngseo's leaving before debut becomes more and more clear to me now: She doesn't like the direction of the group and since she's rich, she doesn't want to do what she doesn't like.

- I feel so bad for Yunah and Minju. BGGB showed they had so much more in them than being forced to a concept that doesn't suit them. Because this is their last chance, they have to accept it. I even suspect the company forced them to say that they like girly concept to shut people up.

- I'm starting to think maybe Jeemin dodged a bullet because she would suit TBL's vibe more (iland2)

Omg this is sad, I had no idea who these girls were and after seeing yesterday stage I would never imagine they could pull off these kind of stages. Esp Yunah, Minju and Moka girl there is so much potential there.

Hybe did them dirty with that copy pasta concept. They could have brought in a new concept centered around these girls strengths and go big.

I find this very sad. I really thought the girls were meh lol