Gidle Vs Mamamoo, which group is more talented?

Gidle! Soyeon is too much

Gidle??? but then again I'm biased

Vocally it's obviously Mamamoo and it's not even close.

As for composing and producing, I think Minnie and Soyeon have really amazing talent in songmaking.

Yuqi is good too but more on the level of Mamamoo members (for songmaking), while Minnie and Soyeon are above them all imo. I'm not talking about writing lyrics (which most Mamamoo credits consist of) but composing the songs melodies and even instrumentals

as a group mamamoo by far

fyi, Soyeon is not the only composer+songwriter in the group. Both Minnie and Yuqi had written great songs too (B sides).

But overall MAMAMOO is still league above. Mainly because they are more balanced as compared to GIDLE

Mamamoo have slightly better vocals. Wheein, Hwasa and Solar are all damn good, but Miyeon and Yuqi are no jokes either, all five have interesting vocal tones that are very distinct, not like 99 percent of the rest of GGs.

But Idle are better performers and of course, the music they write is better as well. I dont think MMM has a single bop while Idle has had some amazing songs like Dumdi, OMG, Wife, Reset, I DO, and 7 Days are all at least 9 out of 10, some 10 out of 10.