who are the TOP 10 KPOP girl group for 3rd gen ?

Quote from girlgroupstan21

1 is either BP or TWICE

2nd is whoever lose on the first round

3rd is fixed for RV

4th is fixed for MMM

5th is fixed for GFRIEND

how about 6th-10th ?

reminder this is only for 3rd gen (2012-2017 groups)

contender might be :Oh My Girl, Lovelyz, WJSN, AOA, MOMOLAND

drop your rank and please try to keep this thread civil

(reminder : no ITZY IZONE GIDLE LOONA no 4th gen group allowed to enter the discussion)

Display More

lmao there is no either

1.BP

wall

2.twice

wall

wall

the rest

i already see one butthurt once being delusional

Quote from bollino

I dont count AOA as 3rd gen since they peaked with 2nd gen gen in 2014-2015 when the first 3rd gen girl group were debuting. Basically for GG the start of 3rd gen was 2014

1. Blackpink higher sales, views and charting than twice but its debatable
2. Twice
3. Red velvet
4. Mamamoo
5. Gfriend
6. Oh my girl good album sales for a girl group and are well known in Korea plus nonstop and dolphin are really big hits
7. Momoland one hit wonder and some member have individual recognition
8. Lovelyz had a sleeper hit with ah choo and big fandom in Korea
9. Ioi this low because they have less than a year of activities but they were doing amazing
10. WJSN they have sales like 100k for each album and have a big Chinese fandom

if we don't count ioi then dreamcatcher or april is 10

it aint debatable

1. Blackpink - consistency

2. Twice

3. Red Velvet

4. Mamamoo

5. Oh My Girl

6. Gfriend

7. Dreamcatcher

8-10: no idea already who to put in each number

1. Blackpink

-not so thick wall-

2. Twice

-GREAT WALL OF CHINA-

3. Red Velvet

4. Mamamoo

5. Gfriend

My question is, what causes the downfall of Gfriend? The 2016 Gfriend was kinda massive but Mamamoo able to surpass Gfriend in 2018 me thinks.

1. Bp

2. Twice

wall

3. Rv

wall

the others

I only love 3 from the 3rd gen:

1. Twice

2. Mamamoo

3. RV