every sm idol steals each other's reject songs

Quote

we've been having this convo for years now. it's time to stop

Then why did you make another thread about it?

I don't get why people that aren't fans of either care about it.

superhuman was a shinee song that nct 127 sang

power was an nct dream song that exo sang

the new shinee song was from boa

ko ko bop was a song red velvet was gonna sing

its how they roll

Quote from hopemin

according to kpop stans

cause I was lurking again and found this:

https://www.allkpop.com/forum/…shinee-reject-song.54268/

who is the true song thief, shinee or nct? i guess it's both of them.

we've been having this convo for years now. it's time to stop. just chillax, stream good music, and support talented, hardworking artists.

Display More

They could have choose a bad song at least

😖

Quote from 7dream0606

omggg what? one of my favorite exo songs was going to be a nct dream song?

its an unconfirmed fact

Quote from hopemin

because the point isn't to say that nct sounded like shinee

i'm just pointing out how these same convos were happening years ago

and people believed the opposite of what people say now

we're just going in circles atp

no need to bash idols over this shit

i was honestly shocked at getting notifs today and finding out that ppl were still arguing about it...

so i feel like one thread clearing things up and pointing out the silliness of the discussion won't hurt

Display More

As the other blink here pointed out, we cant convince nonfans who have predisposed opinions and completely closed off to any reason.

To me what makes sth SHINee like is their representation of the song. Without SHINee member nothing is SHINee like and everything they do is SHINee like whether other people like it or not.

fans are so dumb

some songs don´t fit some artist, even if they wrote it

Quote from yutazenn

superhuman was a shinee song that nct 127 sang

power was an nct dream song that exo sang

the new shinee song was from boa

ko ko bop was a song red velvet was gonna sing

its how they roll

Dream's Chewing Gum was gonna be a Red Velvet song also. SM really just produces/buys random songs and then decides what to do with them later. Its funny thinking so many title tracks could have been swapped.

Artificial Love was supposed go to NCT's discography, but if i'm not wrong, Baekhyun sang the demo and SM decided that EXO will nail it, so it went to EXO.

Became one of the hottest song you can see live.

dang

Quote from hopemin

ig there's no point in trying then

they're not the ones who's opinions matter anyways

exactly. it's no use trying to pin down certain genres and styles when the members are who make SHINee unique.

I wonder if you had time to read some of their recent interviews?

Kibum literally said after doing his service he feels like he doesnt owe anyone anything and he will just do everything he feels like and makes music that makes him happy

I love that attitude