Posts by misterbigfoot

gidle ive and stayc have proven groups don't need great vocal technique for music to sell.

reversely, nmixx is a group full of excellent vocalists but how are their music doing?

its less about their technique and more about half of their voice tone.

how many seconds do you think yuna and ryujin would get if they were in gidle?

in itzy, they combined for 40% of a song.

in which group do the non-vocalist sing 40%?

i will go out on a limb and say their voice tone (thats 2/5 of the group) and line distribution is what holding back their music and the genres they (the other 3) can do.

Quote from buffyfan

I can never predict the popularity rank of the members in Korea lol. To me I thought it would be for this comeback Ryujin, Yuna, Chaeyoung, Lia and then Yeji

their brand reputation ranking has always been

yeji, yuna, lia, ryujin, chaeryeong

and sometimes

yeji, lia, yuna, ryujin chaeryeong

but what matters here is its the first time they re-entered top 13 since 2019

her singing is so stable

Quote from atropos

Pre scandal gidle was bigger than itzy in Korea. Gidle even has a strong Korean fanbase that itzy seems to lack.

yep, ive been saying since last September that gidle is bigger than itzy in Korea

i swear people on this forum can be so out of touch

btw Itzy's ep of Knowing Bros from yesterday recorded 2.4% rating, a 5 years low for the program.

cant force someone to notice an idol. the idol has to do it herself. talents help but its not enough

look at Luna, perhaps the most talented idol of all time after Hyolyn, but the least popular in fx and her releases never garnered public attention. She never lacked solo time in fx either. my guess is because she lacked charisma.

For Chaeryeong its most definitely not a confidence issue. In fact from their everyday vlog and stuff, in terms of performing she has immovable self-confidence. You would see her enthusiastically dance and sing to other idols' songs without being prompted all the time. As to whats missing, i dont know.

Fancams are available for every performance these days so having little center time dont matter as much anymore.

Lia's cant take my eyes off you is the #1 in this chart you posted.

less rap and extend the vocal parts and this song would be a bop

Lia Yeji Chaeryeong vocal subunit please

Like Yuna's, it took a few looks but Lia's bangs is quickly growing on me

NingNing's previous hair looked better

Karina looks better with side parting imo

fromis_9 Nakyung

Quote from bartkun

Chaeryeong is rumored to make debut as actress

woah do you have source for this please?

im imagining how the other 3 would feel

Krystal

why wasnt Yuri there?

who the chubby girl on top right? she adorable

Mina was born in Texas. She is a native speaker

on youtube channels that discuss vocals in the comments people with knowledge found their half live half prerecorded Forever performances underwhelming, at least the 3 of them

could tone down with the dance practice videos and replace some of them with unplugged singing.

Minju