Having high standards on 4th gen boygroups digital performance on kcharts when 3rd gen boygroups ain’t doing well neither

What I’m reading is it’s hard to be EXO. And yes I agree.

Quote from Afriyieau1

Were they very consistent with their digitals, if not I would have already known this

Apart from BTS and big bang the next group who seems to compete well with gg digitals were the disbanded Winner group. Their songs had impressive digitals in boy group standard

What? Winner didn't disband lmao and their latest song last year did worse than Highlight's so longevity goes to them

BEAST/Highlight debuted in 2009 under a new company while Winner debuted under YG in 2014. Two different eras so it's not comparable but Highlight has more hits as group and solos, tho one could say Really Really is the bigger song. They even won daesangs

Thread

Idol Group Melon Unique Listeners Ranking List

I decided to compile the ranking of IDOL GROUP songs Melon Unique Listeners (only with 3M+ ULs, as below that would prove too much).

- Please tell me if I have missed any group, I tried my best to find data for as many groups as I could remember (thank you @myaza for helping me remember to look for a bunch of them).

- I'll try to update it monthly.

Idol Group Melon ULs (3M+)
Rank	Artist	Song	ULs
1	BTS	SPRING DAY	7M
2	BTS	BOY WITH LUV	5.6M
2	TWICE	CHEER UP	5.6M
3	iKON	LOVE SCENARIO	5.5M
4	BTS	DNA

…

worldlove27

Apr 12th 2021

Txt outsold other 4th gen boy groups

nct dream ia charting still?

Quote from reiusagi

nct dream ia charting still?

Yes, hot sauce is still top 70 iirc and dive into you left top 100 after Joy debuted lol

Quote from 4d-maknae

What? Winner didn't disband lmao and their latest song last year did worse than Highlight's so longevity goes to them

BEAST/Highlight debuted in 2009 under a new company while Winner debuted under YG in 2014. Two different eras so it's not comparable but Highlight has more hits as group and solos, tho one could say Really Really is the bigger song. They even won daesangs

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Thread

Idol Group Melon Unique Listeners Ranking List

I decided to compile the ranking of IDOL GROUP songs Melon Unique Listeners (only with 3M+ ULs, as below that would prove too much).

- Please tell me if I have missed any group, I tried my best to find data for as many groups as I could remember (thank you @myaza for helping me remember to look for a bunch of them).

- I'll try to update it monthly.

Idol Group Melon ULs (3M+)
Rank	Artist	Song	ULs
1	BTS	SPRING DAY	7M
2	BTS	BOY WITH LUV	5.6M
2	TWICE	CHEER UP	5.6M
3	iKON	LOVE SCENARIO	5.5M
4	BTS	DNA

…

worldlove27

Apr 12th 2021

When was the last time Winner was active???

Quote from Afriyieau1

When was the last time Winner was active???

Last year...

April 9.