Who wins? 17
-
Group A (13) 76%
-
Group B (4) 24%
Even though some of the female singers in the "Post 2010" debut before 2010, I put them in that category because they rose to fame after 2010
Comparing them when they are around age 27. Sorry if I get their ages wrong for some
Group A
Mariah Carey (Honey - 1997)

Beyonce (Broken Hearted Girl - 2009)

Rihanna (Work - 2016)

Britney Spears (3 - 2009)
Shakira (Hips Don't Lie - 2006)
![]()
Alicia Keys (Doesn't Mean Anything - 2006)
![]()
Group B
Taylor Swift (Look What You Made Me Do - 2017)

Katy Perry (Wide Awake - 2012)

Ariana Grande (Positions - 2020)

Demi Lovato (Ok To Not Be Ok - 2020)

Selena Gomez (Ice Cream - 2020)

Miley Cyrus (Midnight Sky - 2020)
