Variety names Lisa's "New Woman" as one of the worst songs of 2024

  • AllKill VIP
    • New

    The Worst Songs of 2024
    2024's worst songs included stinkers by Katy Perry, Ice Spice, Ye, Jojo Siwa, Nicki Minaj, Julia Fox, Camila Cabello & Playboi Carter and Ben Shapiro.
    variety.com


    Their reasoning was as follows:


    Quote

    *Deep breaths.* Individually, Rosalía and Lisa are virtuosos in crafting immersive worlds to amplify their music. Each an exceptional vocalist in her own right, both are masters of curation, bringing unique aesthetics that extend into their production styles. Together, they unfortunately fall short on “New Woman,” a collaboration that sounds great in theory, but fails in practice. Lisa starts on her own, making the statement that she’s set on a new path of edgy experimentation, hence the title of the track. The upbeat tempo comes to a screeching halt at around the one-minute mark, and suddenly a completely new song begins. Rosalía’s entrance feels disjointed, an obvious marker that artists recorded their part separately, and it doesn’t get any better when Lisa picks back up. —Garcia


    If you want to know what other songs made the list to compare to them, but you don't want to click the link:

    • Katy Perry "Woman's World"
    • Ice Spice "Think U the Shit (Fart)"
    • Nicki Minaj "Big Foot"
    • Jojo Siwa "Karma"
    • Camilla Cabello featuring Playboy Carti "I Luv It"
    • Tom MacDonald featuring Ben Shapiro "Facts"
    • Ye and Ty Dolla $ign "Carnival"
    • Pitbull featuring Jon Bon Jovi "Now or Never"
    • David Guetta featuring OneRepublic "I Don't Wanna Wait"
    • Bailey Zimmerman "New to Country"
    • Julia Fox "Down the Drain"
    • Jason Derulo and Michael Buble "Spicy Margarita"
    • Brian Kelley "Kiss My Boots"
    • Meghan Trainor featuring T-Pain "Benn Like This"

    Thoughts? Haven't heard any of these other songs, so I can't say how it compares.

    Edited once, last by Varenka: katy perry lol ().

  • AllKill VIP
    • New

    Yeah....... it should have been Lisa's own song.


    And I find it funny that Perry's song also titled NW was in the list. ^^^^

    I had to do a double-take and wondered if this thread was a trolling thread because Lisa's was not there ---- until I actually read the quote.

    • New

    Well... I have seen Katy Perry's song, "Think U the Shit (Fart)", "Big Foot", "Karma" and "I Luv It" in a different "Worst Songs of 2024" list.


    About "Now or Never" and "I Don't Wanna Wait", I guess that people are like "I prefer the original version", which is also how I feel about these songs. And I remember when I heard some radio host calling "Now Or Never" an "ear vomit" or something like that.

  • AllKill VIP
    • New
    Quote from JesseAlex

    Yeah....... it should have been Lisa's own song.


    And I find it funny that Perry's song also titled NW was in the list. ^^^^

    I had to do a double-take and wondered if this thread was a trolling thread because Lisa's was not there ---- until I actually read the quote.

    I zoned out at Katy Perry's name for some reason :sweat: "Woman's World" but I did say I haven't heard of any of the songs on the list lol

  • AllKill VIP
    • New
    Quote from Varenka
    • Katy Perry "Woman's World"


    Okay........ Perry's title was fixed.

    • New
    Quote from Varenka

    Their reasoning was as follows:


    *Deep breaths.* Individually, Rosalía and Lisa are virtuosos in crafting immersive worlds to amplify their music. Each an exceptional vocalist in her own right, both are masters of curation, bringing unique aesthetics that extend into their production styles. Together, they unfortunately fall short on “New Woman,” a collaboration that sounds great in theory, but fails in practice. Lisa starts on her own, making the statement that she’s set on a new path of edgy experimentation, hence the title of the track. The upbeat tempo comes to a screeching halt at around the one-minute mark, and suddenly a completely new song begins. Rosalía’s entrance feels disjointed, an obvious marker that artists recorded their part separately, and it doesn’t get any better when Lisa picks back up. —Garcia

    I don't really care about the list, looks accurate tbh, BUT what is that part? This Garcia person is drunk?


    "Exceptional vocalist"? Who? Rosalia and Lisa? Rosalia is average at best, and Lisa is only a "rapper". I don't think either of them are that unique, like, I've seen the same concept multiple times over the years, but let's say that part is true, the concept was nice, but the song can't stand on its own without the MV, like in my cases, not just Lisa's. Honestly, New Woman is probably her best song. I wouldn't put it on "The Worst Songs of 2024" list, that's for sure. Especially if we include everyone, not just Kpop. It was decent, like 6/10. Compared to her other songs, it's like 8/10.


    BTW, it's interesting that we can read more negative reviews about her since she left YGE.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!

Register Yourself Login