2nd gen stans please stop claiming Psy and BoA as 2nd gen singers

Who said BoA was 2nd gen?

Did anyone say Boa was 2nd gen?

I thought everyone knew that they are 1st gen

Quote from omnimorphism

Who said BoA was 2nd gen?

Quote from cherryshiii

Did anyone say Boa was 2nd gen?

Some people do

2nd gen stanszzzzzzzzzzzzz

Quote from Icaro_Ribeiro

forum.allkpop.com/thread/?postID=468238#post468238

I see

people said that

even i know they are 1st gen and i haven't been in the kpop for that long

No

Quote from Icaro_Ribeiro

Still not making him a 2nd gen singer by any means

Dynamite was released in 4th gen, are we now counting any future Blackpink and BTS hit as a 4th gen achievement?

Good point

Quote from pwswan

Maybe we should think of achievements as occurring when they occurred, not by when the performer debuted.

That's what I usually do but kpop fans seem obsessed with generations, mostly 4th gen stans since they can stamp "first group in 4th gen to do it" to every achievement when we know it pales to previous ones

BoA would only debut in 2000, if it was in 2006/2007 then she could be considered 2nd gen, its too much of a time stretch

okay