RE: when do you consider hate and when contructive criticism

    Thread
    When do you consider something 'hate' and when 'constructive criticism'?
    Wondering about that one, because it seems like a fine line that isn't the same to everyone.

    Personally, I usually consider 2 criteria:

    - if the same sort of comment that a poster made would've been said about that poster's bias, would that poster see it as an affront, attack or shade or as a constructive criticism?

    - if a poster keeps on and on in thread after thread about a group's or idol's flaws or lack of success in something, then I don't think it's just criticism anymore.
    OP


    It is a thin line, and I may or may not have an answer. Just know I never hate! :pepelove2:

    I posted it on the other thread as well


    if one gets criticism and the critic uses the words because then it's generally (not always) indicative of CC because they try to explain the why instead of just saying it's not good


    as an example


    your essay is lacking because it failed to address the fundamental differences between the two subjects

    your essay is lacking

    your essay sucks

    yes, absolute statements usually mean its not CC. with CC you're trying to explain eyy.

  • AllKill VIP

    It could also be both!


    Example:

    "Your essay is lacking and your essay sucks because it failed to address the fundamental differences between the two subjects."

    Quote from superyeah

    It could also be both!


    Example:

    "Your essay is lacking and your essay sucks because it failed to address the fundamental differences between the two subjects."

    your comment is lacking and it sucks because it fails to address the fundamental differences between CC and otherwise!!!!


Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!

Register Yourself Login