its not rando internet receipts they actually post transaction receipts and for example sometimes theyll claim theyll put down 50k on ktown4u on a certain day and the sales tally does jump 50k. is that a coincidence? no
and they often spend crazy amounts celebrating idols birthdays with huge billboards and luxury gifts. how do you think they did that, photoshop?
cfans are big spenders admit. you're just anti-china
It did? Because I looked for the latest monthly update on gaon and it doesn't show 700k+ for M&M
External Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
i think he just added the gaon and oricon sales which isnt right because gaon already counts everything
See.... that's rubbish opinion, why cant I say if Twice were treated differently, they would a million seller?
because twice have had ~7 month breaks and it didnt really lead to a significant increase in sales so even if they had a full year break or whatever, realistically they wouldn't jump from 500k to 1M
Display Morechinese importance to kpop is fiction, like most statistics from china.
taiwan and sea each sell about as much as china.
agencies that avoid china (hybe, jype) had record profits even during the pandemic, while those with high china exposure are bleeding money (sme, yge).
sme and yge have even been removed as high quality 'blue-chip' companies.
jype and hype are still blue-chips after rationally focusing on japan and the west, respectively.
its not fiction. cbars post receipts for the massive amounts they buy. its not like they just made it up.
taiwan by itself doesnt buy anywhere near as much as china and SEA is whole region made up of many different countries. but also how would you even know how much theyre buying, those numbers aren't shown anywhere.
you said that last year
i don't think ace is about talent. its more like what an MVP is in a sports team. the ace of a group would be the idol that brings the most attention and profits to the company. like im pretty sure most people would consider irene to be the ace in RV, not wendy. hyuna, irene, yoona, lee hyori are all aces even though they arent very talented.
Just to quickly talk about this, Kworb limited a bunch of the top artist's so their view count on Kworb only count musical content. BLACKPINK are pretty much limited to MVs, Dances, Performances and Behind The Scenes on Kworb. TWICE have most, if not all content types counted (including content from both the JYP Channel and TWICE's channel).
BLACKPINK's actual total is 17.9B.
it’s just MVs and dance practice vids now so it doesn’t include performances or behind the scenes
Do you lack comprehension?
If IU can pull 700k ULs it just means there were at least 400k+ULs or users who could have tuned in to listen to your faves but they didn’t. So the “melon are losing users because my faves have 300kULs and isn’t rising” is false. Just admit your faves are not IU and Koreans didn’t bother to listen to them
so you admit theres less melon listeners now
I remember when they said Melon was losing users because idol songs weren’t rising and ULs were not increasing then IU snatched up 700k ULs with celebrity
but 700k is half of what she used to get. a lot of artists used to get 1M+ so if 700k is a big deal now that just proves melon lost a lot of users
i think it has something to do with the bgm chart. he was #1 on that for the month of april. i think fangirls have discovered new ways to boost digital numbers.
is there a picture?
this is what aespa stans look like
but it’s actually yoon
It’s just not a very fun mv
It's not Blackpink's youtube channel
just as YG owns the group through the contract now, the same way the company owns this youtube channel.
If they won't decide to sign a new contract then the company will probably change its name and promote some new group (if they don't debut Baemon earlier), or they will just keep it and post some videos in the future.
With potential re-branding of the channel in the future when for example they will launch on it some survival show to create a new group.
YG never does that sort of thing. psy and cl still use the same yt channels
google trends
