I rarely post here anymore, but I did want to chime in because I feel threads like these, and the whole idea about what mods should do and what is admissible in a forum has been in need of scrutiny for many years already.
Truth is, the idea here has always been, at least for those in positions of authority in this forum to enable traffic, and the best way has always been to sow discord. I think it's fairly simple to know what is or isn't something that should be said in a discussion, I mean, I know there's many people here who have very little interaction with people in the real world, but we all know that 98 percent of what's said here in the heat of the moment, would never be uttered in real life.
There was a user who mentioned in this thread about there being no repercussion to saying mean, hurtful things to others, and that's where I believe the mods come in, to truly moderate and make this place a safe space for everyone, you have to stop allowing bashing, hate mongering and bullying to happen under the guise of freedom of speech. There's many who argue that criticism should be allowed, but tell me, what value does saying a singer can't sing?, what constructive purpose does it serve? What is the goal aside from trying to rile up that artist's fans?
Ultimately, I feel it's the kpop culture that is the issue, some kpop fans feel that bashing is a part of the community while others do not, and that's why I think there are varying views on the topic, from all parties involved, including the mods. Personally, as a non stan, it's easy to see who is here for discussion and who is here to get off on judging, hating and bashing. I'd personally get rid of those people ASAP.