Should jyp have added at least 1 Chinese or Japanese member to Nmixx or Itzy?

  • They had some good trainees that didn’t make Niziu and both groups currently don’t have any Chinese or Japanese fanbase supporting them, this might have helped. What do you think?

    Discuss

  • Moderator

    Approved the thread.
  • Everyone’s still wondering how nmixx sold this much without cbars or Japan fanbase and jyp stans saying they didn’t buy that many? Very mysterious

  • They had some good trainees that didn’t make Niziu and both groups currently don’t have any Chinese or Japanese fanbase supporting them, this might have helped. What do you think?

    Discuss

    No. JYP's good image is why they have the best fans in the Big3. With how delusional/dangerous SM fans are (+ the xenophobia is always higher for SM Idols because of their fans) and how YG's image is really tanking [went to court for swearing at a trainee] JYP fans stick though everything.


    In Korea with the scandals, really Twice + no foreigners is the reason why JYPggs have a good image off the bat.


    And w/Twice it was really hard for JYP to deal w/foreign members. Knetizens have noticed MiMoSa don't participate in any Korean-history type things and once Twice's image is down will bring it up -- and the Tzuyu thing has really hurt the trajectory of the group too + her mental health. JYP realized it wasn't worth it for his company.


    Also foreign artists can't promote solo in JYP. Foreign line aren't really the type to to solo but it has hurt them with endorsements (Sana during shy/shy, and Tzuyu in particular). Once ITZY promote a bit solo they'll do really well. NMIXX is literally a group of soloists.

  • Everyone’s still wondering how nmixx sold this much without cbars or Japan fanbase and jyp stans saying they didn’t buy that many? Very mysterious

    Nmixx has some Cbar activity for Sullyoon, Jinni, Kyujin and some stuff for Lily.

    But really NMIXX sold so much w/smart marketing, good performances + rebuying for fanmeets.


    However unlike most JYP groups that are good w/public recognition, NMIXX has less.

    They are acknowledged but ITZY, Wonder Girls, Twice were talked about more, but the most noise NMIXX made was for their song + Sullyoon, and their individual talent isn't yet recognized. So basically jyp stans realized NMIXX isn't moving like a typical jypgg and underperformed in their eyes. (They didn't underperform at all).

  • I think that posts like this one prove how delusional/dangerous JYP stans actually are, far more than SM fans or YG fans ever were in 2nd gen times. The ones that are constantly bashing and shading fans of other groups aren't fans of SM or YG groups anymore. It's the so called friendly and peaceful JYP stans and then esp JYP gg stans.


    Having foreigners or not has nothing to do with however good an image a group has.

  • no, smart company should debut member from SEA especially indonesia or phillipines. Huge bonus they are able to speak english. They will carry the streams, views and votings. Knowing mostly ifans are success stan and big3 company stans they will hop on the train.


    Best is stay away from japan and china especially china knowing sk problem with those two. Japan problem comes from dokdo island and rising sun (huge chance to be problematic). China too many to mentions

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!