Stray Kids Yes24 Reason Not Adding Up!

    The fans are making this about 'bundles' which it's not about. The listing on Yes24 says 2 things.


    1: The album is only for Korea.


    2: It counts toward Billboard tally.


    Explain how that works? US fans can't buy this vrsion, only Korean fans, but it counts for BB200 as it clearly states? Is Yes24/Jyp lying in the product discription to drum up sales or are they manipulating sales.


    Jeff's post makes 0 sense as that rule change was about bundles but this ISN'T a bundle at all. This is Korean sales reflecting on BB200 as the product quite clearl states.

  • Moderator

    Approved the thread.

    You’re been banned twice today, repeatedly get shut down with receipts and still refuse to have common sense.


    Nothing can save you from this endless obsession now.

    :pepe-life-support:

    As I said in the thread:


    The thing is, even If Billboard decided they love Stray Kids enough to ignore their rules and counting these few albums being re-sold in Yes24 for koreans, It isn't even relevant to the actual sales. It has around 200-450 index per version. Imagine It converted in real sales. It's nothing.

    Quote from Tenderized Tomatoes & Pork (483)

    As I said in the thread:


    The thing is, even If Billboard decided they love Stray Kids enough to ignore their rules and counting these few albums being re-sold in Yes24 for koreans, It isn't even relevant to the actual sales. It has around 200-450 index per version. Imagine It converted in real sales. It's nothing.

    oh hi bb :oops:

    Billboard biggest stan of Stray Kids, changing rules on their behalf. What's special about them? Hyunjin?

    of course they delighted those responsible for the rules...

    Is it really that relevant? It's not like the imported album is selling something anyway

    Quote from Baked Saffron Rabbit (969)

    You’re been banned twice today, repeatedly get shut down with receipts and still refuse to have common sense.


    Nothing can save you from this endless obsession now.

    :pepe-life-support:

    Not a single receipt or piece of evidence was present.

    Falsehoods were. Not one relevant disproving fact was brought up so I'll ask you, go get them.


    Simple question :: How can an album sell only in Korea but also count on Billboard 200 just like the official listing claims? I'll wait.

    Quote from Tenderized Tomatoes & Pork (483)

    As I said in the thread:


    The thing is, even If Billboard decided they love Stray Kids enough to ignore their rules and counting these few albums being re-sold in Yes24 for koreans, It isn't even relevant to the actual sales. It has around 200-450 index per version. Imagine It converted in real sales. It's nothing.

    Well that could be enough to move up several places. But I see you've come around to the idea that none of the excuses made sense. Does the degree of manipulation not matter? Jyp entertainment is selling an album to Koreans and reporting those sales to reflect on bb 200.

    I doesn't matter if that's 1000 albums of 100,000 it's still chart manipulation.


    Same question:: How can it count for BB200 and only be sold to Koreans?

    Quote from OP

    Not a single receipt or piece of evidence was present.

    Falsehoods were. Not one relevant disproving fact was brought up so I'll ask you, go get them.


    Simple question :: How can an album sell only in Korea but also count on Billboard 200 just like the official listing claims? I'll wait.

    at this point, you’re only hurting yourself like this going in circles. Have your faves made any comebacks of late? Did you enjoy them :oops: perhaps you could occupy yourself with a vid or two of them right now instead

    Quote from OP

    Is it important that 2 of Korea's 4 biggest idol companies has potentially used illegal tactics to manipulate charting? Do you have to ask.

    It's not proven It will count, and It isn't selling a lot and impacting the US sales. So It doesn't matter. People aren't worried about possible companies illegal methods. They are worried about which excuses they will use to dismiss artists achievements. If It's not impacting the achivements, you can sleep in peace.

    Quote from OP

    Well that could be enough to move up several places. But I see you've come around to the idea that none of the excuses made sense. Does the degree of manipulation not matter? Jyp entertainment is selling an album to Koreans and reporting those sales to reflect on bb 200.

    I doesn't matter if that's 1000 albums of 100,000 it's still chart manipulation.


    Same question:: How can it count for BB200 and only be sold to Koreans?

    First of all, Yes24's index points are bigger than the actual sales when converted.

    So no, It's not enough to "move up several places". If you retire these sales, they would still be around 20-30k ahead of the second place in the prediction.


    If you want to start a revolution because of a a dozen copies, okay. Go ahead.

    Quote from Pickled Mint & Orange Bear (155)

    It's not proven It will count, and It isn't selling a lot and impacting the US sales. So It doesn't matter. People aren't worried about possible companies illegal methods. They are worried about which excuses they will use to dismiss artists achievements. If It's not impacting the achivements, you can sleep in peace.

    It isn't proven it will count. I did offer an alternative choice for that option and that is questioning if the product description is lying.

    But is that the best we can hope for? From a company as big a jyp? That they lie about manipulating billboard sales as an exclusive album sweetener?Kind of pathetic from them.


    But again this has equal chance of being true as option A, jyp is indeed attempting to manipulate the chart in the exact same way SM did. By falsely registering Korean sales as US ones, a tactic that we know worked in the past.

    op not only giving us nothing on 2 alts but in anons as well. atleast they’re consistent.


    Post this on your main and get an allkill.

    4173-strip-pole-dancing-flushed.gif

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!

Register Yourself Login