I think that without Wonyoung IVE would be nothing

duh...she brought with her her huge fandom from iz*one

they still have yujin. the group would've been doing fine even without both but it's true they wouldn't be among the top groups in 4th gen

I think Wonyoung was a big contributor but I also enjoy Ive's songs so far and they're all super pretty and have nice voices to listen to.

Nothing is a stretch but kinda true, she's the main reason for ive's success

Quote from azhra-0110

Nothing is a stretch but kinda true, she's the main reason for ive's success

sure...they wouldn't be nothing, but they also wouldn't be one of the top groups of gen 4.5.

Quote from 0ppar

sure...they wouldn't be nothing, but they also wouldn't be one of the top groups of gen 4.5.

i think it's too soon to call them 4.5 gen. we don't even know when this gen will end

I like yujin

Quote from cherryshiii

I think Wonyoung was a big contributor but I also enjoy Ive's songs so far and they're all super pretty and have nice voices to listen to.

Your sig

And to answer the question, no they might not have been as big but there would still be hype for their debut and starship isnt a small company or new to groups. They have good songs and they'd be promoted so i'm sure they'd be fine regardless.