Throwback to the time 12 year old NINGNING made the audience cry through her voice

Cute, didn't SM scout her from here?

I think she was also in a few concerts at Harbin because they have many festivals, but I don't think they have any clips on the internet.

Oh this is so cute!!!

Quote from nityasingh

Yes, SM called her due to her various appearances in the tv show.

No wonder she is so confident on stage (wish i could be like that)

Wow I wish I had a voice like that... I'm only a year older than her in this clip

Quote from frozenolaf

Wow I wish I had a voice like that... I'm only a year older than her in this clip

I know right? If people heard me sing they'd run

Also apprently Ningning had done some light modelling and predebut people found some of the pictures too?

Quote from SendFoodPics

I know right? If people heard me sing they'd run

Also apprently Ningning had done some light modelling and predebut people found some of the pictures too?

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Wowww that's gorgeous

Quote from frozenolaf

Wowww that's gorgeous

IKR

Quote from frozenolaf

Wowww that's gorgeous

Off topic but who is that in your sig again? I can't remember her name but I remember watching her

Quote from nityasingh

She's HITOMI from IZONE.

She looks good! Thanks~

You know what I just discovered last week, Winter also used to perform to audiences with a guitar, it was on some fan account on instagram (Just pictures)

That's Ningx2 in shows, Karina in School performances, Giselle in choir and Winter to audiences too

aespa are really something else

Quote from evo-evolution

You know what I just discovered last week, Winter also used to perform to audiences with a guitar, it was on some fan account on instagram (Just pictures)

That's Ningx2 in shows, Karina in School performances, Giselle in choir and Winter to audiences too

aespa are really something else

:OOO wow Mys really digging things up

Quote from SendFoodPics

:OOO wow Mys really digging things up

Yeah they had a before debut picture and she was sat with a guitar infront of audiences, I was really surprised, but it makes sense why's she so good

MY's are literally detectives it's insane

Quote from evo-evolution

Yeah they had a before debut picture and she was sat with a guitar infront of audiences, I was really surprised, but it makes sense why's she so good

MY's are literally detectives it's insane

Was this a high school thing? Impressive

Quote from SendFoodPics

Was this a high school thing? Impressive

no she wasn't In uniform, just regular clothes and the audience didn't look like students, bare in mind it was the back and sides of their heads in the picture but the setting looked like some cafe? I'll try and fine the pics!!

Quote from evo-evolution

no she wasn't In uniform, just regular clothes and the audience didn't look like students, bare in mind it was the back and sides of their heads in the picture but the setting looked like some cafe? I'll try and fine the pics!!

A cafe? That takes guts...