I don’t think Rose will chart in top 10 melon

Based on her 3 previous song, she will definitely enter top 10, whether she can earn #1 depends on her competitor at the time. If the song well received like Apt, then she will easily score #1 on all domestic chart.

she is rose, not jihyo or nayeon

If Jennie can, she will

Her only real competition is herself, aespa, Day6, Jennie and GD right now. She'll get top 10, but it's unlikely she'll dethrone APT.

all her previous solo releases have hit top10

Why would this be an exception? Especially riding the momentum of APT.

it's may not be another APT but she surely will get into top 10

She'll do well, she's always been knetz favourite. The only reason she made no noise previously was her bland music.